Vehicular Homicide Attorneys in Orlando, FL

Attorney’s Comprehensive Guide to Vehicular Homicide in Florida

Understanding the Core Elements of Vehicular Homicide in Florida

In the State of Florida, vehicular homicide holds significant legal implications. As outlined under Sec. 782.071 of the Florida Statutes, this grave offense is defined by specific criteria that the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt. These criteria, or ‘elements’, shape the foundation of the charge and are pivotal in legal proceedings.

The elements of Vehicular Homicide in Florida can be summarized as:

  1. Reckless Operation of a Motor Vehicle: It’s not just about causing an accident; the state mandates that the person accused must have operated the vehicle recklessly. This means that the manner in which the vehicle was driven was likely to result in death or inflict significant bodily harm upon another individual.
  2. Direct Causation of Death: The reckless operation of the motor vehicle should directly lead to the death of another human being. This includes situations where an unborn child succumbs to injuries sustained by the mother as a direct result of the incident.

Distinction Between Negligence and Recklessness

It’s imperative to understand that to be charged with vehicular homicide in Florida, the State needs to provide more substantial evidence than mere negligence. While negligence refers to a lapse in duty or care that a reasonably prudent person would have exercised, recklessness encompasses a more egregious form of behavior.

For Vehicular Homicide, recklessness signifies willful and wanton conduct. This suggests that the accused acted with a conscious disregard or intentional indifference for the safety of others. Essentially, the driver was aware that their actions or conduct possessed a high risk of causing significant bodily harm or death, yet chose to proceed regardless of these glaring dangers.

The Burden of Proof

For a successful conviction, the State is burdened with the responsibility to prove each of these elements unequivocally. It’s not sufficient to merely demonstrate that the defendant’s driving resulted in death. They must establish, beyond a reasonable doubt, that the defendant’s actions were borne out of recklessness, thereby endangering the lives of others.

In summary, understanding the intricacies and nuances of vehicular homicide in Florida is crucial for legal practitioners. It’s not just about the act but the intent and level of recklessness that underscores the offense. Every detail plays a pivotal role in shaping the outcome of the case.

Penalties for Vehicular Homicide in Florida

Florida has stringent measures in place when it comes to punishing those found guilty of Vehicular Homicide. The consequences are severe, emphasizing the importance the state places on safe driving and the inherent value of human life.

Classification and Basic Penalties

In Florida, Vehicular Homicide is classified as a second-degree felony. This classification entails a series of grave repercussions, including:

    • A potential imprisonment term of up to 15 years or an equivalent probation period.
    • A substantial fine, which can be as high as $10,000.

Offense Severity Level Points Minimum Sentence Maximum Sentence
Vehicular Homicide 7 176 111 months (9.25 years) 15 years
Vehicular Homicide (without providing information and rendering aid) 8 194 124.5 months (10 years and 4 months) 30 years

Detailed Breakdown of Penalties by Severity

The penalties for Vehicular Homicide can be further detailed according to the severity of the offense:

  • Vehicular Homicide:
    • Severity Level: 7
    • Accumulated Points: 176 (56 from severity level + 120 for the victim’s death)
    • Minimum Sentence: 111 months (approximately 9.25 years)
    • Maximum Sentence: 15 years
  • Vehicular Homicide (with failure to provide information and aid)
    • Severity Level: 8
    • Accumulated Points: 194
    • Minimum Sentence: 124.5 months (approximately 10 years and 4 months)
    • Maximum Sentence: 30 years

Florida’s Criminal Punishment Code uses a point-based system, where specific offenses are assigned a certain number of points. Vehicular Homicide carries a base severity level of 7, which translates to 56 points. Given the gravity of causing someone’s death, an additional 120 points are added, bringing the total points for the offense to 176. These points play a direct role in determining the minimum allowable sentence.

The Importance of Minimum Sentence

It’s essential to note that, given the calculated points and absent any other extenuating factors, the court mandates a minimum sentence of 111 months or 9.25 years. The judge’s hands are effectively tied to this minimum, and any lesser sentence can only be pronounced if specific, exceptional conditions allow for a “downward departure” from the predetermined sentence.

Additional Penalties

Beyond imprisonment and financial penalties, the court can also mandate the guilty party to engage in community service. A unique feature of this penalty is its nature; those found guilty may be required to serve 120 hours in institutions like hospitals or trauma centers. These are places where the aftermath of vehicular accidents is most palpable, aiming to make the convict more acutely aware of the consequences of their actions.

In essence, Florida’s penalties for Vehicular Homicide reflect a blend of punitive measures and rehabilitative efforts, intending not just to punish the offender but also to make them recognize the profound impact of their actions.

How to Fight a Charge of Vehicular Homicide in Florida

Being charged with vehicular homicide in Florida can be overwhelming and intimidating. However, understanding the potential defense strategies can make a significant difference in the outcome of a case. Below, we delve deeper into these strategies, offering a more comprehensive understanding of each:

  1. Exclusion of Improperly Obtained Evidence: The U.S. Constitution ensures specific rights for individuals. If evidence was procured in violation of these rights, such as conducting a search without a valid warrant or coercing a confession, a defense attorney could move to have this evidence excluded from the trial.
  2. Challenge the Evidence’s Validity: It’s crucial to meticulously analyze the evidence presented by the State. If it’s found that there is no substantial evidence backing the charge, this can be a strong foundation for your defense.
  3. Presenting an Alibi: If you can prove that you were elsewhere when the alleged incident occurred, this can negate the charges. Alibi witnesses or concrete evidence, such as surveillance footage or transaction records, can be invaluable.
  4. Contesting DUI Test Results: If you were subjected to DUI tests, their accuracy and the procedures followed during administration can be challenged. Factors like machine calibration, officer training, or even your medical conditions can affect the test results.
  5. Medical Conditions as a Defense: If reckless driving occurred due to a sudden medical emergency, such as a seizure or heart attack, it might be argued that the behavior was uncontrollable and not a result of negligence.
  6. Questioning the Degree of Negligence: The State must prove not just negligence, but gross negligence or recklessness. If it can be shown that your actions were not grossly negligent or entirely devoid of care, this can weaken the prosecution’s case.
  7. Involuntary Intoxication Defense: In rare circumstances, if you were unknowingly drugged or consumed a substance without being aware of its intoxicating effects, you can argue involuntary intoxication as a defense.
  8. Challenging the Cause of Death: Even if reckless driving is proven, the direct causation between your actions and the victim’s death must be established. If there were other factors involved, like another vehicle’s intervention or a pre-existing medical condition in the victim, it could be argued that your actions weren’t the direct cause of death.
  9. Arguing Insufficiency of Evidence: The prosecution must meet a high burden of proof. If they cannot provide enough evidence to satisfy this burden, arguing that the evidence is insufficient can be a robust defense strategy.
  10. Claiming Mistaken Identity: In instances where the prosecution’s case relies heavily on eyewitness testimonies, it’s possible these witnesses could be mistaken. If there’s a chance that another person was the actual culprit, proving mistaken identity can be pivotal.

Vehicular homicide charges in Florida are grave, but with a well-crafted defense strategy, there’s potential to challenge the State’s case. It’s imperative to work closely with a competent defense attorney who understands these intricacies and can tailor the best strategy based on the unique circumstances of your case.


1. What role do witness testimonies play in vehicular homicide cases in Florida?

Witness testimonies can play a pivotal role in both supporting and refuting the allegations. Eyewitness accounts of the incident, the accused’s behavior, or the accident’s aftermath can significantly impact the case’s outcome. However, it’s essential to evaluate the reliability and accuracy of these testimonies.

2. How do vehicular homicide laws in Florida compare to neighboring states?

Florida’s vehicular homicide laws are rigorous, and while there are similarities with neighboring states, each state has its nuances regarding definitions, penalties, and the legal process. It’s essential to consult with a local attorney when dealing with cross-border incidents.

3. Can vehicular homicide charges be expunged from one’s record in Florida?

Expunging a criminal record in Florida is complex and contingent on several factors, including the nature of the crime, the outcome of the case, and the individual’s prior criminal history. Vehicular homicide, given its gravity, can be challenging to expunge, but certain circumstances might allow for it.

4. How do plea deals work in the context of vehicular homicide cases in Florida?

Plea deals or plea agreements involve the defendant agreeing to plead guilty to a lesser charge in exchange for a reduced sentence or the dismissal of other charges. In vehicular homicide cases, plea deals depend on the evidence’s strength, the circumstances surrounding the incident, and prosecutorial discretion.

5. How do insurance companies typically respond to vehicular homicide charges in Florida?

Facing vehicular homicide charges can lead to significant implications for the accused’s insurance. Insurers might increase premiums substantially or even drop coverage. Additionally, they may be reluctant to cover the damages from the incident if it’s determined that the driver acted recklessly.

6. How do restitution and compensations work in Florida vehicular homicide cases?

Restitution involves the convicted person compensating the victim’s family for financial losses incurred due to the incident. This can include funeral costs, medical bills, or lost wages. This is separate from any civil lawsuit damages and is typically determined during the criminal sentencing process.

7. If a vehicular homicide incident involves multiple victims, how does it impact the charges and penalties?

Multiple victims can lead to multiple counts of vehicular homicide, each carrying its penalties. The overall severity and the potential prison term can increase substantially when more than one person is fatally injured due to the defendant’s actions.

Even if drugs or alcohol levels are below legal limits, their presence can still influence the perception of recklessness or impairment. This could bolster the prosecution’s case, especially if it can be shown that the substances contributed to the alleged reckless behavior.

Why Choose Leppard Law for Your Defense?

Navigating the complex world of criminal law requires a partner you can trust. Leppard Law, Florida DUI Lawyers & Criminal Defense Attorneys PLLC, consistently emerges as a top choice. But you don’t have to just take our word for it. Here’s why we stand out:

What does it look like to have a personal relationship with your attorney?

Someone who has your back when things get tough? A lawyer that knows you as well as they know your case? At Leppard Law, we treat our clients like family. We always prioritize their best interests and relentlessly fight for the optimal outcome in their case. If you or a loved one find yourself facing a criminal charge, don’t hesitate. Call or text us today for a free consultation about your case. 407-476-4111. Contact us today!

Our Actions Speak Louder

We will always have your back. Take a look at our recent victories and see for yourself.

A Culture of Excellence

Our carefully vetted legal experts carry a breadth of experience unlike any you’ll find.

Get a Free Case Evaluation

When you’re ready to talk, we’re here for you! Get your free consultation today.