fbpx

Can Insurance Deny My Claim if there is Evidence of Alcohol or Drugs Involved?



Understanding Florida’s Drug and Alcohol Exclusion Law

Florida’s Drug and Alcohol Exclusion Law allows insurance companies to deny claims if alcohol or drugs are involved in the incident. This law is often referred to as the “intoxication exclusion” or “drunkenness exclusion.” Insurance policies may contain specific provisions that exclude coverage for any loss incurred due to injuries sustained while under the influence of alcohol or drugs, unless prescribed by a physician.

History and Adoption of the Alcohol Exclusion Law

The model Alcohol Exclusion Law was created in the 1940s as part of the Uniform Accident and Sickness Policy Provision (UPPL). It was adopted by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) in 1947, and subsequently, many states, including Florida, incorporated it into their laws. This provision allows insurers to deny claims if there is evidence of alcohol or drug involvement.

What is an intoxication exclusion? An intoxication exclusion is a provision in an insurance policy that denies coverage for any loss incurred due to injuries sustained while under the influence of alcohol or drugs, unless administered by a physician.

Florida’s Drug and Alcohol Exclusion Law is particularly significant in cases involving DUI crashes. When an accident occurs and the driver is found to be under the influence, insurance companies often invoke this exclusion to deny coverage for injuries or damages. This can leave victims in a difficult financial situation, especially when facing medical bills and other expenses.

However, it’s important to note that people taking medications as prescribed by a doctor are usually found to be outside the scope of these statutes. This means that if you are taking prescribed medication and are involved in an accident, the intoxication exclusion may not apply to your case. For more information on how DUI impacts insurance, visit our page on DUI effects on auto insurance.

Problems with Alcohol Exclusion Laws

The alcohol or intoxication exclusion policy has created several public policy problems. One major issue is that the medical community has developed policies against testing for or documenting drug or alcohol impairment due to fear that insurance claims would be denied. This can lead to underreporting of substance use and hinder efforts to address substance abuse as a medical condition.

In 2001, recognizing these issues, the NAIC revised the UPPL to remove the model Alcohol Exclusion Law. Despite this revision, only 14 states plus the District of Columbia have taken action to repeal or amend their laws to prohibit drug and alcohol exclusions in health insurance policies. Unfortunately, Florida has not taken such action, meaning that insurers in the state can still deny claims associated with alcohol or drug use.

Florida’s stance on this issue often comes into play in DUI crashes involving personal injuries, serious bodily injury, or death. Insurance companies can use the intoxication exclusion to avoid paying claims, which can have severe financial consequences for the victims and their families. To understand more about the broader implications of DUI, check out our guide on collateral consequences of DUIs.

Florida Law on Alcohol Exclusion Policies

In Florida, case law has further defined the application of alcohol exclusion provisions. For instance, in Am. Heritage Life Ins. Co. v. Morales, 159 So. 3d 160 (Fla. 3d DCA 2015), the court concluded that an alcohol exclusion or drunkenness exclusion provision would bar recovery of benefits if there is “some” causal relationship between the insured’s intoxication and his death. This means that the insurer does not need to prove that alcohol was the sole cause of death, only that it contributed to the incident.

Another significant case is Harris v. Carolina Life Ins. Co., 233 So.2d 833 (Fla. 1970), where the Florida Supreme Court considered an alcohol exclusion provision in an accidental death policy. The court held that an insurer must show a causal relationship between the death and the intoxication for the exclusionary provision to be effective. This case set a precedent that requires insurers to demonstrate some connection between the insured’s intoxication and the resulting injury or death.

These legal precedents highlight the complexities of navigating insurance claims involving alcohol or drug use in Florida. If you find yourself in such a situation, understanding these laws and how they apply to your case is crucial. For more insights on the legal consequences of DUI, visit our comprehensive guide on how a DUI affects your life in Florida.

How Florida’s Alcohol Exclusion Law Affects Insurance Claims

Can Insurance Deny My Claim if there is Evidence of Alcohol or Drugs Involved?

Under Florida law, insurance companies can deny claims if there is a causal relationship between the insured’s intoxication and the injury or death. This means that if alcohol or drugs contributed to the incident, the insurer has the right to deny the claim. This law is particularly relevant in cases involving DUI crashes, where personal injuries, serious bodily injury, or death occur.

Several court cases have established the application of Florida’s Alcohol Exclusion Law. For instance, in Am. Heritage Life Ins. Co. v. Morales, the court ruled that an alcohol exclusion provision would bar recovery of benefits if there is “some” causal relationship between the insured’s intoxication and death. Similarly, in Harris v. Carolina Life Ins. Co., the Florida Supreme Court held that insurers must show a causal relationship between death and intoxication for the exclusion to be effective.

What is Florida’s Alcohol Exclusion Law? Florida’s Alcohol Exclusion Law allows insurance companies to deny claims if there is a causal relationship between the insured’s intoxication and the injury or death.

In Harris v. Carolina Life Ins. Co., the insured was intoxicated by alcohol while riding as a passenger in an automobile when he was killed in a car crash. The parties acknowledged that no causal connection existed between the accident and the insured’s intoxication, but the insurer argued that the provision excluded coverage whether or not the insured’s intoxication played any role in his death. The Court rejected this argument, stating that the insurer must show some causal relationship between the death and the intoxication for the exclusionary provision to be effective.

Another notable case is English v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., where a life insurance policy included an alcohol exclusion provision that stated: “[This] policy does not cover any loss incurred as a result of … Any injury sustained while under the influence of alcohol or any narcotic unless administered upon the advice of a physician.” The appellate court concluded that the alcohol exclusion provision applied because the insurer met its burden of showing a causal relationship between the insured’s accident and intoxication.

Implications for DUI Cases

Florida’s Alcohol Exclusion Law can have significant implications for insurance claims, especially in DUI cases. If a person is injured or killed in a DUI crash, the insurance company may deny the claim if there is evidence of intoxication. This can lead to financial hardships for victims and their families, who may be left without coverage for medical expenses or loss of income.

For example, in cases where the insured was driving under the influence and caused an accident, the insurance company can argue that the intoxication directly contributed to the incident. This allows them to invoke the alcohol exclusion provision and deny the claim. Such a scenario can be devastating for victims who rely on insurance payouts for recovery and financial stability.

How does Florida’s Alcohol Exclusion Law impact DUI cases? In DUI cases, Florida’s Alcohol Exclusion Law allows insurance companies to deny claims if there is evidence that intoxication contributed to the incident, leading to potential financial hardships for victims and their families.

Steps to Take if Your Claim is Denied

If your insurance claim is denied due to the alcohol exclusion provision, it is crucial to seek legal advice. An experienced DUI attorney can help you understand your rights and explore options for appealing the denial. They can also assist in gathering evidence to challenge the insurer’s decision and negotiate a fair settlement.

  • Review the policy: Carefully review the terms of your insurance policy to understand the specific language of the alcohol exclusion provision.
  • Gather evidence: Collect any evidence that may counter the insurer’s claim that intoxication was a contributing factor. This may include witness statements, medical records, and expert testimony.
  • Consult an attorney: A knowledgeable DUI attorney can provide valuable guidance and representation throughout the appeals process.
  • File an appeal: If the initial claim is denied, you may have the option to file an appeal with the insurance company. Your attorney can help you present a strong case for reconsideration.

Understanding the nuances of Florida’s Alcohol Exclusion Law and how it affects insurance claims is essential for anyone involved in a DUI accident. By seeking expert legal advice and taking proactive steps, you can navigate the complexities of insurance claims and work towards a favorable outcome.

For more information on how DUI impacts insurance and other related matters, you can explore our detailed guide on DUI Effects on Auto Insurance.

Challenges and Controversies Surrounding Alcohol Exclusion Policies

Alcohol exclusion policies have sparked significant debate and criticism due to the public policy issues they create. One of the primary concerns is that these policies may discourage medical professionals from testing for or documenting drug or alcohol impairment. The fear that insurance claims will be denied can lead to underreporting of substance use, which in turn hinders efforts to address substance abuse as a medical condition.

Revisions and Current Status

Recognizing the negative impact of alcohol exclusion laws on public health, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) revised the Uniform Accident and Sickness Policy Provision (UPPL) in 2001 to remove the model Alcohol Exclusion Law. Despite this revision, only a few states have taken action to repeal or amend the statutory authority that allows these exclusions. Unfortunately, Florida has not prohibited drug or alcohol exclusions in health and life insurance policies, which means insurers can continue to deny claims associated with alcohol or drug use.

What is the status of alcohol exclusion laws in Florida? Despite revisions by the NAIC, Florida has not prohibited drug or alcohol exclusions in health and life insurance policies, allowing insurers to deny claims associated with alcohol or drug use.

In practice, this means that if an insured individual is involved in an incident where alcohol or drugs are a factor, their insurance claim may be denied. This can be particularly problematic in DUI cases, where the consequences of a denied claim can be severe. For example, victims of DUI crashes may find themselves without coverage for medical expenses or loss of income, leading to significant financial hardships.

Furthermore, the continued existence of alcohol exclusion policies in Florida can create a chilling effect on the medical community. Physicians may avoid performing blood alcohol concentration (BAC) tests or documenting alcohol use in medical records to prevent their patients’ insurance claims from being denied. This underreporting can obscure the true extent of substance abuse issues and impede efforts to provide appropriate treatment and support.

For those involved in DUI cases, the implications of alcohol exclusion policies are far-reaching. If you find yourself in this situation, it’s crucial to understand your rights and the steps you can take to challenge a denied claim. Seeking legal advice from a knowledgeable DUI attorney can make a significant difference in navigating these complex legal waters.

For more information on how DUI charges can impact various aspects of your life, you can explore our detailed guide on the collateral consequences of DUIs.

Additionally, understanding the effects of DUI on auto insurance rates can help you prepare for potential financial impacts. It’s also important to be aware of how a DUI can affect your life insurance premiums and other related matters.

By staying informed and seeking expert legal advice, you can better navigate the challenges posed by Florida’s alcohol exclusion policies and work towards a favorable outcome in your case.


Implications for DUI Cases and Insurance Claims

In DUI cases, Florida’s Alcohol Exclusion Law can have significant implications for insurance claims. If a person is injured or killed in a DUI crash, the insurance company may deny the claim if there is evidence of intoxication. This can lead to financial hardships for victims and their families, who may be left without coverage for medical expenses or loss of income.

Florida’s Drug and Alcohol Exclusion Law allows insurance companies to deny claims if alcohol or drugs are involved in the incident. This law is often referred to as the “intoxication exclusion” or “drunkenness exclusion.” Insurance policies may contain specific provisions that exclude coverage for any loss incurred due to injuries sustained while under the influence of alcohol or drugs, unless prescribed by a physician.

What is an intoxication exclusion? An intoxication exclusion is a provision in an insurance policy that excludes coverage for any loss incurred due to injuries sustained while under the influence of alcohol or drugs, unless administered by a physician.

For victims of DUI crashes, this exclusion can be particularly devastating. Imagine being involved in a severe accident caused by a drunk driver, only to find out that your insurance claim is denied because of the intoxication exclusion. This leaves you to shoulder the burden of medical bills, lost wages, and other expenses on your own.

Steps to Take if Your Claim is Denied

If your insurance claim is denied due to the alcohol exclusion provision, it is crucial to seek legal advice. An experienced DUI attorney can help you understand your rights and explore options for appealing the denial. They can also assist in gathering evidence to challenge the insurer’s decision and negotiate a fair settlement.

Here are some steps you can take if your claim is denied:

  1. Review Your Policy: Carefully read through your insurance policy to understand the specific language of the alcohol exclusion provision.
  2. Gather Evidence: Collect all relevant evidence, including medical records, police reports, and witness statements, to support your case.
  3. Consult with an Attorney: Seek the assistance of a knowledgeable DUI attorney who can guide you through the appeals process and help you build a strong case.
  4. File an Appeal: Work with your attorney to file an appeal with the insurance company, providing all necessary documentation and evidence to support your claim.
  5. Consider Legal Action: If the insurance company continues to deny your claim, your attorney can help you explore the possibility of filing a lawsuit to seek the compensation you deserve.

It’s important to act quickly if your claim is denied, as there may be specific deadlines for filing appeals or taking legal action. An experienced attorney can help ensure that you meet all necessary deadlines and maximize your chances of a successful outcome.

For those dealing with the aftermath of a DUI crash, understanding the broader consequences of a DUI is also crucial. For instance, a DUI conviction can significantly impact your auto insurance rates, leading to higher premiums and potential difficulties in obtaining coverage.

Additionally, a DUI can affect other aspects of your life, such as your life insurance premiums and even your ability to travel internationally. It’s essential to be aware of these potential consequences and seek professional guidance to navigate them effectively.

In some cases, the emotional toll of a DUI arrest can be overwhelming. If you or a loved one is struggling with the emotional impact of a DUI, consider exploring resources on coping with the emotional toll of a DUI arrest.

By staying informed and seeking expert legal advice, you can better navigate the challenges posed by Florida’s alcohol exclusion policies and work towards a favorable outcome in your case. Remember, you don’t have to face this alone—experienced DUI attorneys are here to help you every step of the way.

Legal books related to Can Insurance Deny My Claim if there is Evidence of Alcohol or Drugs Involved?


Infographic depicting the words Can Insurance Deny My Claim if there is Evidence of Alcohol or Drugs Involved?


Can insurance deny my claim if I was under the influence of alcohol or drugs?

Yes, under Florida’s Drug and Alcohol Exclusion Law, insurance companies can deny claims if there is evidence that alcohol or drugs contributed to the incident. This is often referred to as the “intoxication exclusion” or “drunkenness exclusion.”

What should I do if my insurance claim is denied due to alcohol or drug involvement?

If your insurance claim is denied due to alcohol or drug involvement, it is crucial to seek legal advice. An experienced DUI attorney can help you understand your rights, gather evidence, and file an appeal. They can also assist in negotiating a fair settlement or exploring the possibility of filing a lawsuit.

Are there any exceptions to the alcohol exclusion policy in Florida?

Yes, there are exceptions to the alcohol exclusion policy in Florida. For example, people taking medications prescribed by a doctor and taking them as prescribed are usually found to be outside the scope of these statutes. Additionally, insurers must show a causal relationship between the intoxication and the injury or death for the exclusion to be effective.

How does Florida’s Alcohol Exclusion Law impact DUI cases?

Florida’s Alcohol Exclusion Law can have significant implications for DUI cases. If a person is injured or killed in a DUI crash, the insurance company may deny the claim if there is evidence of intoxication. This can lead to financial hardships for victims and their families, who may be left without coverage for medical expenses or loss of income.

Explore additional practice areas and related pages that may be relevant to your case:

Collateral Consequences of DUI DUI Consequences for Non-Citizens
Emotional Toll of DUI Arrest DUI Impact on Child Custody
DUI Impact on Family Life DUI Effects on Auto Insurance
DUI Disclosure to Employers DUI Complications with International Travel
Personal Injury Lawsuits After DUI DUI Effect on Credit Score
Obtaining FR-44 Insurance After DUI Traveling to Canada After DUI
DUI Influence on Life Insurance Passport Eligibility After DUI
DUI Effect on Life in Florida Life Ruined After DUI

Top-Rated DUI Lawyers Serving Florida

Choosing the appropriate legal representation is crucial when pursuing a claim. A seasoned, committed DUI attorney ensures you’re equipped to make informed choices at each phase of the process.

  • John Vallillo: As a stalwart in the Florida legal scene, John Vallillo has earned his stripes through a consistent record of case dismissals and proactive defense. His background as both a prosecutor and defense attorney enriches his strategic defense planning with invaluable insights.
  • Joe Easton: Renowned for crafting winning defenses, Joe Easton’s approach to legal advocacy in Florida combines thorough preparation with aggressive representation. His notable recognitions and ratings stand testament to his exceptional service and client-focused approach.
  • Joel Leppard: Joel Leppard infuses every DUI case with a level of personal commitment and innovative thinking that sets him apart. His leadership has not only grown Leppard Law into a top-rated criminal defense law firm but also ensured that clients receive empathetic, effective legal care.

Discover What Our Clients Are Saying

For us, commitment isn’t just a word; it’s our action plan. We channel this into vigorous work on every case, and the glowing reviews we receive are a gratifying sign of our successful client relationships. You can read more 5-star reviews here.








Contact Leppard Law for Expert DUI Defense

Facing a DUI charge can be overwhelming, but you don’t have to navigate this challenging time alone. At Leppard Law, we treat our clients like family, always putting your best interests first and fighting for the best possible outcome for your case.

Our team of top-rated DUI attorneys has been recognized for their dedication and expertise, including being named among the “Best DUI Lawyers in Orlando” by Expertise in 2024. We bring a unique combination of legal skill and personal commitment to every case we handle.

But don’t just take our word for it. Here are some of our notable accolades:

  • SuperLawyers “Rising Star” 2019-2020: Recognized by SuperLawyers for outstanding professional achievement and peer recognition. Learn more
  • Awesome Attorneys Orlando 2019-2023: Selected by readers of Orlando Family Magazine and legal peers. Discover why
  • Top 10 DUI Attorneys near Orlando, FL 2024: Highlighted by Thumbtack for our exceptional service and client satisfaction. Find out more
  • Top 5 DUI Attorneys near Palm Coast, FL 2024: Recognized by Thumbtack for our outstanding legal defense in DUI cases. Read reviews
  • Martindale Hubbell “Client Champion Platinum” 2018-2024: Less than 1% of attorneys selected for exceptional client service. See why

At Leppard Law, our commitment to excellence has earned us numerous accolades, but our true pride lies in the trust and satisfaction of our clients. Whether you’re dealing with a DUI charge or any other criminal offense, our experienced attorneys are here to provide the support and legal expertise you deserve.

Don’t let a DUI charge define your future. Contact Leppard Law today at 407-476-4111 to schedule a free consultation and take the first step towards securing your defense. Experience the difference of having a dedicated legal team that truly cares about your case and your well-being.

We understand that dealing with a DUI charge can be stressful. Let us make getting the help you need as painless as possible. Reach out to us now and see why we’ve been named among the best in the field.

Trusted Content


Legally Reviewed by Joe Easton

Experienced Florida DUI Attorney

Legally reviewed by Joe Easton and the content team, this article reflects the firm’s 60 years of combined criminal defense expertise. Joe Easton, with his extensive experience and strategic prowess in DUI and criminal defense, offers more than just legal representation; he brings a commitment to turning legal challenges into triumphs. His approach, combining tenacity in the courtroom with personalized client care, ensures your DUI case is not just defended but championed with dedication and expertise.

Learn More About Joe Easton