fbpx

Can Insurance Deny My Claim if there is Evidence of Alcohol or Drugs Involved?




Can Insurance Deny My Claim if There is Evidence of Alcohol or Drugs Involved?

In Florida, insurance companies can deny claims if there is evidence that alcohol or drugs were involved in the incident. This is due to the state’s drug and alcohol exclusion laws, which allow insurers to exclude coverage for injuries sustained while under the influence of alcohol or drugs. This provision is often referred to as the “intoxication exclusion” or “drunkenness exclusion.”

Understanding the Intoxication Exclusion

Insurance policies with an intoxication exclusion clause will not cover any loss incurred as a result of injuries sustained while the insured was under the influence of alcohol or drugs. This means that if you are involved in an accident and there is evidence that you were intoxicated, your insurance claim could be denied. The rationale behind this exclusion is to discourage risky behaviors and reduce the financial burden on insurance companies.

For instance, if you were involved in a car accident and your blood alcohol concentration (BAC) was above the legal limit, your insurance company might invoke the intoxication exclusion to deny your claim. This can be particularly challenging if the accident resulted in significant medical expenses or property damage.

What is an intoxication exclusion? An intoxication exclusion is a provision in an insurance policy that denies coverage for any losses incurred as a result of injuries sustained while the insured was under the influence of alcohol or drugs.

It’s important to note that these exclusions are not limited to auto insurance policies. Health and life insurance policies can also contain intoxication exclusion clauses. For example, if someone dies in an accident and it is determined that alcohol or drugs played a role in the incident, the life insurance company may deny the claim based on the intoxication exclusion.

These exclusions can have far-reaching consequences, especially in cases of personal injury lawsuits following a DUI crash. Victims may find it difficult to secure compensation for their injuries if the at-fault driver was intoxicated at the time of the accident.

Understanding the implications of the intoxication exclusion is crucial for anyone involved in an accident where alcohol or drugs are a factor. If you find yourself in this situation, it may be beneficial to consult with an experienced DUI attorney who can help you navigate the complexities of your insurance policy and fight for your rights.

Florida’s Drug and Alcohol Exclusion Law

Florida’s drug and alcohol exclusion law permits insurance companies to deny claims if the insured’s intoxication contributed to the injury or death. This law is part of the Uniform Accident and Sickness Policy Provision (UPPL), which many states adopted in the 1940s. Although some states have repealed or amended these provisions, Florida has not, meaning the exclusion remains in effect.

Drug Defense Lawyer

The model Alcohol Exclusion Law was created in the 1940s and adopted by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). Despite revisions to the UPPL in 2001 to remove the alcohol exclusion, Florida has not taken action to prohibit these exclusions in health and life insurance policies. As a result, insurers in Florida can deny claims associated with alcohol or drug consumption.

To understand the implications, it’s crucial to explore the historical context and legal precedents that have shaped the current landscape:

  • Origins: The model Alcohol Exclusion Law was part of the UPPL adopted in the 1940s. It aimed to mitigate the financial risks for insurers by excluding coverage for injuries sustained while under the influence of alcohol or drugs.
  • NAIC Adoption: The National Association of Insurance Commissioners adopted the model language in 1947, leading to widespread adoption across states, including Florida.
  • Revisions: In 2001, the NAIC revised the UPPL to remove the alcohol exclusion. However, Florida did not adopt these revisions, maintaining the exclusion in its insurance policies.

These historical steps have cemented the exclusion’s place in Florida’s insurance landscape, affecting many policyholders.

Implications for Policyholders

The implications of Florida’s drug and alcohol exclusion law are far-reaching, particularly for individuals involved in accidents where alcohol or drugs are a factor. Here are some key points to consider:

  • Denial of Claims: If an insurer can demonstrate that intoxication contributed to the injury or death, they can deny the claim. This can leave policyholders without coverage for significant medical expenses or property damage.
  • Legal Burden: Insurers must show a causal relationship between the intoxication and the injury or death. This means they need to prove that the intoxication directly contributed to the incident.
  • Medical Documentation: Healthcare providers may avoid testing for or documenting drug or alcohol impairment due to fear of claim denials. This can lead to underreporting of substance use and inadequate treatment for those affected.

It’s essential for policyholders to be aware of these implications and seek legal advice if they find themselves in a situation where their claim is denied due to the intoxication exclusion.

What is Florida’s drug and alcohol exclusion law? Florida’s drug and alcohol exclusion law allows insurance companies to deny claims if the insured’s intoxication contributed to the injury or death.

Understanding these nuances can be particularly important in cases of personal injury lawsuits after a DUI crash. Victims may struggle to secure compensation if the at-fault driver was intoxicated, making it crucial to consult with an experienced attorney.

Moreover, this exclusion can affect various types of insurance policies, including health, life, and auto insurance. For instance, if someone dies in an accident and it is determined that alcohol or drugs played a role, the life insurance company may invoke the exclusion to deny the claim. This can be devastating for beneficiaries who rely on the policy for financial support.

Several legal cases have addressed the issue of alcohol exclusion in insurance policies, providing valuable insights into how courts interpret these provisions:

  • Am. Heritage Life Ins. Co. v. Morales: The court concluded that an alcohol exclusion provision would bar recovery of benefits if there is “some” causal relationship between the insured’s intoxication and their death.
  • Harris v. Carolina Life Ins. Co.: The Florida Supreme Court ruled that insurers must demonstrate a causal link between the death and intoxication for the exclusion to be effective.

These cases highlight the legal burden on insurers to prove a causal relationship between intoxication and the incident. This means that policyholders and beneficiaries have a potential avenue to challenge claim denials if the insurer cannot establish this link.

For those facing such challenges, consulting with a knowledgeable DUI attorney can provide critical guidance and support. An experienced attorney can help navigate the complexities of insurance policies and legal precedents, ensuring that your rights are protected.

In summary, Florida’s drug and alcohol exclusion law has significant implications for policyholders. Understanding the historical context, legal precedents, and potential challenges can help individuals navigate these complex situations and seek the compensation they deserve.

Challenges and Public Policy Issues

The alcohol exclusion policy has created several public policy problems. One significant issue is that medical professionals may avoid testing for or documenting drug or alcohol impairment out of fear that insurance claims will be denied. This can lead to underreporting of substance use and inadequate treatment for those affected by alcohol or drug-related injuries.

Impact on Medical Treatment and Reporting

Because of the potential for insurance claim denials, some healthcare providers may choose not to test for blood alcohol concentration (BAC) or document drug use in medical records. This can result in a lack of accurate data on substance use and hinder efforts to provide appropriate medical care and support for individuals struggling with addiction.

Here are some key impacts:

  • Underreporting of Substance Use: Medical professionals may avoid documenting cases of substance use to prevent insurance denials, leading to inaccurate health records.
  • Inadequate Treatment: Without proper documentation, patients may not receive the necessary treatment and support for addiction, potentially exacerbating their condition.
  • Public Health Concerns: The lack of accurate data on substance use can hinder public health initiatives aimed at addressing addiction and its related consequences.

These challenges underscore the need for a comprehensive approach to addressing substance use and ensuring that individuals receive the care they need without fear of insurance claim denials.

What is the impact of Florida’s alcohol exclusion law on medical treatment? The alcohol exclusion law can lead to underreporting of substance use and inadequate treatment for individuals affected by alcohol or drug-related injuries.

Moreover, the fear of claim denials can also affect the accuracy and reliability of medical data. For instance, healthcare providers might avoid BAC tests or fail to document drug use in medical reports, which can have far-reaching consequences for patient care and public health initiatives.

Public Policy Concerns

Florida’s alcohol exclusion law raises several public policy concerns. These include:

  • Encouraging Risky Behavior: The law may inadvertently encourage risky behavior by not holding individuals accountable for the consequences of their actions while under the influence of alcohol or drugs.
  • Legal and Ethical Dilemmas: Medical professionals face ethical dilemmas in deciding whether to document substance use, balancing the need for accurate medical records with the potential for insurance claim denials.
  • Impact on Vulnerable Populations: Vulnerable populations, such as those struggling with addiction, may face additional barriers to receiving appropriate care and support due to the fear of insurance claim denials.

These public policy concerns highlight the need for a balanced approach that addresses the complexities of substance use and ensures that individuals receive the care and support they need.

Additionally, the financial burden of fines, legal fees, and mandatory programs can be overwhelming. If you’re a professional, such as a nurse or a commercial airline pilot, a DUI conviction can jeopardize your career and professional license.

Why is Florida’s alcohol exclusion law a public policy concern? The law raises concerns about encouraging risky behavior, creating legal and ethical dilemmas for medical professionals, and impacting vulnerable populations.

Another crucial aspect is understanding how urine tests are used in DUI-Drug arrests. The implications of these tests can be significant, especially in the context of the alcohol exclusion law.

In conclusion, Florida’s alcohol exclusion law presents numerous challenges and public policy issues. Addressing these concerns requires a comprehensive approach that balances the need for accurate medical reporting with the goal of providing appropriate care and support for individuals affected by substance use.


Several legal cases have addressed the issue of alcohol exclusion in insurance policies. In Florida, courts have ruled that insurers must show a causal relationship between the insured’s intoxication and the injury or death to deny a claim. This means that the insurer must prove that the intoxication directly contributed to the incident.

Notable Court Rulings

In the case of Am. Heritage Life Ins. Co. v. Morales, 159 So. 3d 160, 164 (Fla. 3d DCA 2015), the court concluded that an alcohol exclusion provision would bar recovery of benefits if there is “some” causal relationship between the insured’s intoxication and their death. Similarly, in Harris v. Carolina Life Ins. Co., 233 So.2d 833–34 (Fla. 1970), the Florida Supreme Court ruled that insurers must demonstrate a causal link between the death and intoxication for the exclusion to be effective.

What is the burden of proof for insurers under Florida’s alcohol exclusion law? Insurers must show a causal relationship between the insured’s intoxication and the injury or death to deny a claim.

These rulings underscore the importance of proving a direct connection between intoxication and the incident. Without this proof, the exclusion cannot be applied, and the claimant may still be entitled to benefits.

Case Examples

Let’s dive into some specific cases to better understand how these rulings play out in real life:

  • Am. Heritage Life Ins. Co. v. Morales: In this case, the court ruled that an alcohol exclusion provision could bar recovery of benefits if there was “some” causal relationship between the insured’s intoxication and their death.
  • Harris v. Carolina Life Ins. Co.: The Florida Supreme Court held that insurers must demonstrate a causal link between the death and intoxication for the exclusion to be effective. This ruling emphasized that a mere presence of alcohol was not enough to deny a claim; a direct connection must be established.
  • English v. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Florida, Inc., 786 So.2d 1279 (Fla. 5th DCA 2001): In this case, the insured was killed in a car accident, and the court found that the insurer met its burden of showing a causal relationship between the insured’s accident and intoxication. The appellate court ruled that the alcohol exclusion provision applied because the insurer showed that the insured fell asleep at the wheel due to alcohol consumption.

These cases highlight the critical role of establishing a causal link between intoxication and the incident in question. Without this link, insurers cannot rely on the alcohol exclusion provision to deny claims.

Understanding the legal landscape surrounding alcohol exclusion laws is crucial for anyone involved in a DUI crash with personal injuries, serious bodily injury, or death. If you find yourself in such a situation, it’s essential to seek legal advice to navigate the complexities of these laws and protect your rights.

Implications for Policyholders

The implications of these court rulings are significant for policyholders. Here are some key takeaways:

  • Proof of Causation: Insurers must prove that intoxication directly contributed to the incident to deny a claim. This means that the presence of alcohol alone is not sufficient grounds for denial.
  • Legal Precedents: Court rulings such as Am. Heritage Life Ins. Co. v. Morales and Harris v. Carolina Life Ins. Co. provide a framework for understanding how these cases are evaluated and the burden of proof required.
  • Policyholder Rights: Policyholders have the right to challenge claim denials based on alcohol exclusion provisions. Legal assistance can help navigate these challenges and ensure that their rights are protected.

For example, if you’re facing a DUI charge, understanding the role of mitigation in DUI proceedings can be crucial for your defense strategy.

What should policyholders know about alcohol exclusion provisions? Policyholders should understand that insurers must prove a direct causal relationship between intoxication and the incident to deny a claim based on alcohol exclusion provisions.

Moreover, if you’re a professional, such as a nurse or a commercial airline pilot, a DUI conviction can jeopardize your career and professional license. Understanding the legal nuances and seeking expert legal advice can help protect your livelihood.

Additionally, the financial burden of fines, legal fees, and mandatory programs can be overwhelming. If you’re a professional, such as a nurse or a commercial airline pilot, a DUI conviction can jeopardize your career and professional license.

Understanding the implications of Florida’s drug and alcohol exclusion law is crucial for anyone involved in an incident where alcohol or drugs may be a factor. If you’re facing a situation where your insurance claim is denied due to an alcohol exclusion provision, seeking legal advice can help you navigate these challenges and protect your rights.

For more information on how DUI charges can impact various aspects of your life, explore our comprehensive guides on collateral consequences of DUIs and DUI effects on auto insurance.

Remember, understanding your rights and the legal landscape can make a significant difference in the outcome of your case. If you need assistance, don’t hesitate to contact Leppard Law: DUI Lawyers at 407-476-4111 for expert legal advice and representation.

Legal Books


Infographic depicting the words Can Insurance Deny My Claim if there is Evidence of Alcohol or Drugs Involved?


Can insurance deny my claim if I was not at fault but had alcohol in my system?

Yes, insurance can deny your claim if you had alcohol in your system, even if you were not at fault. Florida’s drug and alcohol exclusion laws allow insurers to deny coverage if the insured was under the influence of alcohol or drugs at the time of the incident. This exclusion applies regardless of fault.

What should I do if my insurance claim is denied due to alcohol or drug use?

If your insurance claim is denied due to alcohol or drug use, you should take the following steps:

  • Review your insurance policy to understand the terms and exclusions.
  • Gather all relevant evidence, such as medical records and accident reports.
  • Contact an experienced attorney to help you challenge the denial.

Seeking legal advice can help you navigate the complexities of Florida’s insurance laws and potentially overturn the denial.

Are there any exceptions to Florida’s drug and alcohol exclusion law?

Yes, there are exceptions to Florida’s drug and alcohol exclusion law. For instance, if the insured was taking medication prescribed by a doctor and following the prescribed dosage, they may be outside the scope of the exclusion. It’s important to consult with a legal expert to understand if any exceptions apply to your specific situation.

How can I prove that my intoxication did not contribute to the accident?

To prove that your intoxication did not contribute to the accident, you may need to:

  • Gather eyewitness testimonies that support your case.
  • Obtain expert opinions, such as accident reconstruction specialists.
  • Collect medical evidence showing that your intoxication level was not a contributing factor.

Working with an attorney can help you compile the necessary evidence to challenge the insurance company’s denial.

For more information on how DUI charges can impact various aspects of your life, explore our comprehensive guides on collateral consequences of DUIs and DUI effects on auto insurance.


Other Practice Areas We Serve

Explore additional practice areas we specialize in to see how we can assist you with your legal needs:

Collateral Consequences of DUI DUI Consequences for Non-Citizens
Emotional Toll of DUI Arrest DUI Impact on Child Custody
DUI Impact on Family Life DUI Effects on Auto Insurance
DUI Disclosure to Employers DUI Complications with International Travel
Personal Injury Lawsuits After DUI DUI Effect on Credit Score
Obtaining FR-44 Insurance After DUI Traveling to Canada After DUI
DUI Influence on Life Insurance Passport Eligibility After DUI
DUI Effect on Life in Florida Life Ruined After DUI

Top-Rated DUI Lawyers Serving Florida

Looking for the best DUI lawyers in Florida? Our distinguished team of attorneys is committed to offering you the best possible defense against your DUI charges.

  • John Vallillo: As a stalwart in the Florida legal scene, John Vallillo has earned his stripes through a consistent record of case dismissals and proactive defense. His background as both a prosecutor and defense attorney enriches his strategic defense planning with invaluable insights.
  • Joe Easton: Renowned for crafting winning defenses, Joe Easton’s approach to legal advocacy in Florida combines thorough preparation with aggressive representation. His notable recognitions and ratings stand testament to his exceptional service and client-focused approach.
  • Joel Leppard: Joel Leppard infuses every DUI case with a level of personal commitment and innovative thinking that sets him apart. His leadership has not only grown Leppard Law into a top-rated criminal defense law firm but also ensured that clients receive empathetic, effective legal care.

Discover What Our Clients Are Saying

At the forefront of our DUI practice is a deep-seated commitment to client satisfaction. Each case is handled with utmost care, as echoed in the appreciative feedback from those we represent. Stellar reviews are what make us one consistently one of Central Florida’s top-rated DUI law firms. You can read more 5 star reviews here: https://leppardlaw.com/reviews/








Take Control of Your Case Today

At Leppard Law, we understand the stress and uncertainty that comes with dealing with a criminal charge, especially when it involves alcohol or drugs. Our team of experienced DUI attorneys is here to provide you with the support and legal expertise you need. We treat our clients like family, always putting their best interests first and fighting for the best possible outcome.

But don’t just take our word for it. Our dedication to client satisfaction has earned us numerous accolades:

  • SuperLawyers “Rising Star” – SuperLawyers, 2019-2020. Only 1.5 percent of lawyers selected by their peers. View Award
  • Awesome Attorneys Orlando – Orlando Family Magazine, 2019-2023. As selected by readers and legal peers. View Award
  • Top 10 DUI Attorneys near Orlando, FL – Thumbtack, 2024. Recognized for excellence in DUI defense. View Award
  • Top 10 Best DUI Lawyers Near Volusia County, Florida – Yelp, 2024. Highlighted among the best in Volusia County. View Award
  • Top 10 Traffic Attorneys near Winter Garden, FL – Thumbtack, 2024. Recognized for excellence in traffic law. View Award

We invite you to experience our award-winning service for yourself. If you or a loved one have been charged with a criminal offense, don’t wait. Contact us today to schedule a free consultation and let us put our expertise to work for you.

Call us now at 407-476-4111 or visit our contact page to get started.


Trusted Content


Legally Reviewed by Joe Easton

Experienced Florida DUI Attorney

Legally reviewed by Joe Easton and the content team, this article reflects the firm’s 60 years of combined criminal defense expertise. Joe Easton, with his extensive experience and strategic prowess in DUI and criminal defense, offers more than just legal representation; he brings a commitment to turning legal challenges into triumphs. His approach, combining tenacity in the courtroom with personalized client care, ensures your DUI case is not just defended but championed with dedication and expertise.

Learn More About Joe Easton