fbpx

How Lack of Probable Cause for Your DUI Arrest Can Get Your Breath Test or Refusal Thrown Out?



Understanding Probable Cause in DUI Arrests

Probable cause is a critical element in DUI arrests. It refers to the reasonable belief that a person has committed a crime. In the context of DUI, probable cause means that the officer must have a valid reason to believe you were driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs. Without probable cause, any evidence obtained, such as breath test results or refusal, may be inadmissible in court.

What Constitutes Probable Cause in DUI Cases?

Probable cause can be established through various observations and evidence, including:

  • Erratic driving behavior: Swerving, speeding, or driving too slowly.
  • Physical signs of intoxication: Slurred speech, bloodshot eyes, or unsteady balance.
  • Field sobriety test results: Failing to perform tasks like walking in a straight line or standing on one leg.
  • Odor of alcohol or drugs: Detectable smell of alcohol or marijuana from the vehicle or person.

Understanding what constitutes probable cause is essential for challenging a DUI arrest. If the arresting officer lacked probable cause, your DUI lawyer could argue that your breath test or refusal should be thrown out.

Probable cause in DUI cases is established through observations such as erratic driving, physical signs of intoxication, field sobriety test results, and odor of alcohol or drugs.

For instance, if you were pulled over without any legitimate reason or the officer’s observations were inconsistent, this could be grounds to challenge the probable cause. Your lawyer will meticulously review the circumstances surrounding your arrest, including dashcam and bodycam footage, to identify any discrepancies or procedural errors.

By challenging the lack of probable cause, your lawyer can potentially get your breath test results or refusal thrown out, weakening the prosecution’s case against you. This is a common defense strategy in DUI cases, and it can have a significant impact on the outcome of your case.

For more information on how to challenge the legality of a DUI stop, you might find our guide on defending unlawful DUI stops beneficial. Additionally, understanding the definition of probable cause can further aid in building a strong defense.

If you’re facing a DUI charge, it’s crucial to consult with experienced DUI defense lawyers who can navigate the complexities of your case. At Leppard Law, we specialize in DUI defenses and are committed to protecting your rights. Learn more about our comprehensive DUI defense strategies to understand how we can assist you in fighting your charges.

Challenging the Lack of Probable Cause in DUI Arrests

How Lack of Probable Cause for Your DUI Arrest Can Get Your Breath Test or Refusal Thrown Out?

Challenging the lack of probable cause is a common defense strategy in DUI cases. Your DUI lawyer will scrutinize the circumstances of your arrest to determine if the officer had a valid reason to stop you and conduct a DUI investigation. This process involves a meticulous examination of all available evidence and procedural details to identify any potential violations or inconsistencies.

How DUI Lawyers Challenge Probable Cause

DUI lawyers employ various methods to challenge probable cause, ensuring that every aspect of the arrest is thoroughly investigated. These methods include:

  • Reviewing dashcam and bodycam footage: These recordings can reveal whether the officer had a legitimate reason to stop you. Any discrepancies between the officer’s report and the footage can be used to challenge the probable cause.
  • Examining the officer’s report for inconsistencies: Inconsistencies or errors in the officer’s report can undermine the credibility of the probable cause. Your lawyer will look for any deviations from standard procedures or conflicting statements.
  • Questioning the validity of field sobriety tests: Field sobriety tests are subjective and can be influenced by various factors, such as medical conditions or environmental conditions. Your lawyer will scrutinize the administration and interpretation of these tests.
  • Investigating any potential violations of your rights: Any violation of your constitutional rights, such as unlawful searches or detentions, can be grounds to challenge the probable cause. Your lawyer will ensure that all procedures were followed correctly.

By challenging the lack of probable cause, your lawyer can potentially get your breath test results or refusal thrown out, significantly weakening the prosecution’s case against you. This approach can be particularly effective in cases where the initial stop or subsequent investigation was flawed or unjustified.

Reviewing Dashcam and Bodycam Footage

Dashcam and bodycam footage are invaluable tools in DUI defense. These recordings provide an objective account of the events leading up to and during the arrest. Your lawyer will carefully review this footage to identify any discrepancies or procedural errors. For example, if the footage shows that you were driving normally and did not exhibit any signs of impairment, this could be used to argue that the officer lacked probable cause for the stop.

Additionally, the footage can reveal whether the officer followed proper procedures during the traffic stop and subsequent DUI investigation. Any deviations from standard protocols can be used to challenge the legality of the arrest. For more information on how to leverage this type of evidence, refer to our detailed guide on using bodycam footage in DUI defense.

Examining the Officer’s Report for Inconsistencies

The officer’s report is a crucial piece of evidence in any DUI case. Your lawyer will meticulously examine this report for any inconsistencies or errors. This includes checking for conflicting statements, incorrect information, or deviations from standard procedures. For instance, if the report indicates that you failed a field sobriety test but the dashcam footage shows otherwise, this discrepancy can be used to challenge the probable cause.

It’s also important to ensure that the officer’s observations are consistent with the evidence. If the officer claims that you exhibited signs of intoxication, such as slurred speech or unsteady balance, but these signs are not evident in the footage, this can further undermine the probable cause. Understanding the reasonable suspicion for DUI stops can provide additional insights into this aspect of your defense.

Questioning the Validity of Field Sobriety Tests

Field sobriety tests are often used by officers to establish probable cause for a DUI arrest. However, these tests are not always reliable indicators of impairment. Various factors, such as medical conditions, fatigue, or poor weather conditions, can affect a person’s performance on these tests. Your lawyer will scrutinize the administration and interpretation of the field sobriety tests to identify any potential issues.

For example, if the tests were conducted on an uneven surface or in poor lighting conditions, this could have impacted your performance. Additionally, if you have a medical condition that affects your balance or coordination, this should be taken into consideration. Challenging the validity of these tests can be a powerful strategy in your defense. To learn more about this, explore our article on medical issues mistaken for DUI.

Investigating Potential Violations of Your Rights

Any violation of your constitutional rights during a DUI stop or arrest can be grounds to challenge the probable cause. This includes unlawful searches, detentions, or interrogations. Your lawyer will ensure that all procedures were followed correctly and that your rights were not violated at any point during the process.

For instance, if the officer conducted a search of your vehicle without your consent or a valid warrant, this could be a violation of your Fourth Amendment rights. Similarly, if you were detained for an excessive amount of time without probable cause, this could also be grounds for a challenge. Understanding the limits of police detention during DUI stops can provide valuable insights into this aspect of your defense.

Challenging the lack of probable cause in DUI arrests involves reviewing dashcam and bodycam footage, examining the officer’s report for inconsistencies, questioning the validity of field sobriety tests, and investigating any potential violations of your rights.

By employing these strategies, your DUI lawyer can build a strong defense and potentially get your breath test results or refusal thrown out. This can significantly weaken the prosecution’s case and improve your chances of a favorable outcome. For a comprehensive overview of defense strategies, check out our ultimate guide to DUI defenses in Florida.

The Impact of Lack of Probable Cause on Breath Test Results

If it is determined that the arresting officer lacked probable cause, any evidence obtained as a result of the arrest, including breath test results, may be deemed inadmissible in court. This can significantly impact the outcome of your DUI case. The absence of probable cause can render the breath test results invalid, potentially leading to the dismissal of charges or a reduction in penalties.

Why Breath Test Results May Be Thrown Out

Breath test results may be thrown out if:

  • The officer did not have a valid reason to stop you: Without a legitimate reason for the initial stop, any subsequent evidence, including breath test results, can be challenged.
  • The officer failed to follow proper procedures: Law enforcement must adhere to strict protocols when administering breath tests. Any deviation from these procedures can result in the evidence being invalidated.
  • There were technical issues with the breathalyzer device: Breathalyzer devices must be properly maintained and calibrated. Technical issues or malfunctions can compromise the accuracy of the test results.
  • Your rights were violated during the arrest: Any violation of your constitutional rights, such as unlawful search and seizure, can lead to the exclusion of breath test results from evidence.

Getting breath test results thrown out can greatly improve your chances of a favorable outcome in your DUI case. This is especially true if the prosecution’s case heavily relies on the breath test as primary evidence of impairment. By challenging the validity of the breath test, your DUI lawyer can weaken the prosecution’s case and create opportunities for a more favorable resolution.

Key Factors in Challenging Breath Test Results

Several key factors can be leveraged to challenge the admissibility of breath test results:

  • Officer’s Observations: If the officer’s observations leading to the stop and arrest are inconsistent or unsupported, this can be used to challenge the probable cause for the breath test. For example, if the officer claimed you were driving erratically, but dashcam footage shows otherwise, this discrepancy can be critical in your defense.
  • Field Sobriety Test Administration: The manner in which field sobriety tests were conducted can also be scrutinized. Any errors or irregularities in the administration of these tests can undermine the probable cause for the breath test.
  • Calibration and Maintenance Records: Breathalyzer devices require regular calibration and maintenance to ensure accuracy. Your lawyer can request these records to identify any potential issues that could affect the reliability of the test results. For more on this, see our article on how calibration and maintenance affect breathalyzer results.
  • Officer’s Training and Certification: The officer administering the breath test must be properly trained and certified. Any deficiencies in the officer’s qualifications can be grounds for challenging the test results.

What happens if breath test results are thrown out? If breath test results are deemed inadmissible, the prosecution loses a key piece of evidence, significantly weakening their case and increasing the likelihood of a favorable outcome for the defendant.

By examining these factors, your DUI lawyer can build a strong case for challenging the breath test results. This approach can be particularly effective in cases where the initial stop or subsequent investigation was flawed or unjustified. For a comprehensive overview of defense strategies, check out our ultimate guide to DUI defenses in Florida.

Consequences of Invalid Breath Test Results

The consequences of having breath test results thrown out can be profound. Without this critical piece of evidence, the prosecution may struggle to prove impairment beyond a reasonable doubt. This can lead to several potential outcomes:

  • Dismissal of Charges: In some cases, the lack of admissible evidence may result in the dismissal of DUI charges altogether.
  • Reduction of Charges: The prosecution may be forced to negotiate a plea deal, resulting in reduced charges or penalties.
  • Improved Defense Strategy: With the breath test results excluded, your lawyer can focus on other aspects of your defense, such as challenging the officer’s observations or the administration of field sobriety tests. For more information on effective defense strategies, refer to our article on how to beat your DUI case.

It’s important to note that the exclusion of breath test results does not automatically guarantee a favorable outcome. However, it significantly weakens the prosecution’s case and enhances your chances of a successful defense. By working with an experienced DUI lawyer, you can ensure that every possible avenue is explored to challenge the evidence against you.

If you find yourself facing DUI charges and believe that the arresting officer lacked probable cause, it’s crucial to seek legal assistance immediately. At Leppard Law, our experienced DUI lawyers are dedicated to protecting your rights and providing the best possible defense. Contact us today to discuss your case and explore your legal options.


The Consequences of Refusing a Breath Test Without Probable Cause

Refusing a breath test can have serious consequences, including license suspension and additional criminal charges. However, if it can be proven that the officer lacked probable cause, the refusal may be thrown out, mitigating these consequences.

Defending Against Breath Test Refusal Charges

Your DUI lawyer can defend against breath test refusal charges by:

  • Arguing that the officer lacked probable cause: If the officer did not have a valid reason to believe you were under the influence, the refusal may be invalidated.
  • Demonstrating that you were not properly informed of the consequences of refusal: Officers must clearly inform you of the consequences of refusing a breath test. Failure to do so can be a strong defense.
  • Showing that you were confused or misled by the officer: Confusion, especially if Miranda rights were read close to the implied consent warning, can be a valid defense.
  • Providing evidence of any medical conditions that prevented you from taking the test: Conditions like asthma or other respiratory issues can prevent a person from successfully completing a breath test.

By effectively defending against breath test refusal charges, your lawyer can help reduce or eliminate the penalties associated with your DUI case.

What are the penalties for refusing a breath test in Florida? Refusing a breath test can lead to a 12-month license suspension for the first refusal and an 18-month suspension for subsequent refusals, with no hardship permits for repeat offenders.

Refusing a breath test in Florida can lead to severe consequences, including immediate license suspension. Florida treats driving as a privilege, not a right, and by obtaining a driver’s license, you agree to submit to breath tests if requested by law enforcement. If you refuse, the officer has the right to confiscate your license on the spot. However, there are ways to challenge this suspension and potentially get your license back quickly.

License Suspension Periods

The duration of your license suspension depends on whether this is your first refusal or a subsequent one:

  • First refusal: A possible 12-month suspension, with a 90-day period where you are ineligible for any hardship license.
  • Subsequent refusals: An 18-month suspension with no eligibility for a hardship permit.

If you have prior DUI convictions, refusing a breath test can complicate matters further. For example, if you have two prior DUI convictions and refuse a breath test upon a third arrest, you could face a 12-month suspension with no hardship permit. If this is your third DUI arrest and you have previously refused a breath test, the suspension could extend to 18 months without eligibility for a hardship permit.

Refusing a breath test can also be used as evidence of guilt. Prosecutors may argue that your refusal indicates a consciousness of guilt, suggesting that you knew you were impaired. However, there are numerous reasonable explanations for refusing a breath test that have nothing to do with guilt, such as distrust of the breathalyzer’s accuracy or fear of providing false evidence.

The worst consequence of refusing a breath test is that it can lead to additional criminal charges if you have refused before. Florida law allows for a first-degree misdemeanor charge purely for refusing a breath test if you have previously refused. This means you could face separate charges for the refusal in addition to the DUI.

Defenses to a Refusal

Fortunately, there are several defenses available to challenge a breath test refusal:

  • Lack of Compliance with the Implied Consent Statute: If the officer did not have probable cause to believe you were under the influence, the refusal could be thrown out.
  • Improper Reading of Implied Consent Warning: Officers must read a specific warning before requesting a breath test. Any deviation from this can be grounds for defense.
  • Confusion Doctrine: If you were confused by the reading of your Miranda rights and the implied consent warning, this could be a valid defense.
  • Medical Conditions: Conditions like asthma or other respiratory issues can prevent you from successfully completing a breath test.
  • Language Barrier: If English is not your first language and you did not understand the implied consent warning, this could be a defense.
  • Changing Your Mind: If you initially refused but quickly changed your mind and the officer did not allow you to take the test, this could be a defense.
  • Head Trauma: If you suffered head trauma in an accident, this could impair your ability to make an informed decision about the breath test.
  • Officer Misconduct: If the officer provided incorrect information about the penalties for refusal, this could be a defense.
  • Failure to Provide an Alternative Test: If you requested a blood test after refusing a breath test and the officer did not comply, this could be a defense.

What is the Confusion Doctrine? The Confusion Doctrine states that if you are confused by the reading of your Miranda rights and the implied consent warning, your refusal to take a breath test may be invalidated.

By leveraging these defenses, your DUI lawyer can challenge the refusal and potentially get the charges reduced or dismissed. For more information on how to beat your DUI case, see our comprehensive guide on winning DUI strategies.

If you are facing DUI charges and refused a breath test, it’s crucial to seek legal assistance immediately. At Leppard Law, our experienced DUI lawyers are dedicated to protecting your rights and providing the best possible defense. Contact us today to discuss your case and explore your legal options.

How Lack of Probable Cause for Your DUI Arrest Can Get Your Breath Test or Refusal Thrown Out?


Infographic depicting the words How Lack of Probable Cause for Your DUI Arrest Can Get Your Breath Test or Refusal Thrown Out?


What does probable cause mean in a DUI arrest?

Probable cause in a DUI arrest means that the officer must have a reasonable belief that you were driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs. This belief must be based on observable facts such as erratic driving behavior, physical signs of intoxication, or field sobriety test results.

How can a DUI lawyer challenge the lack of probable cause?

A DUI lawyer can challenge the lack of probable cause by scrutinizing the circumstances of your arrest. This includes reviewing dashcam and bodycam footage, examining the officer’s report for inconsistencies, questioning the validity of field sobriety tests, and investigating any potential violations of your rights.

What happens if there was no probable cause for my DUI arrest?

If it is determined that there was no probable cause for your DUI arrest, any evidence obtained as a result of the arrest, including breath test results, may be deemed inadmissible in court. This can significantly impact the outcome of your DUI case, potentially leading to the dismissal of charges.

Can refusing a breath test be justified if there was no probable cause?

Yes, refusing a breath test can be justified if there was no probable cause for the DUI arrest. If it can be proven that the officer lacked probable cause, the refusal may be thrown out, mitigating the consequences such as license suspension and additional criminal charges.

Explore additional practice areas we serve to understand how we can assist you in various legal matters:

DUI Defense Guide Winning DUI Strategies
Strengthen DUI Defense Motion to Suppress Impact
Intervening Causes in DUI Duress DUI Defense
Involuntary Intoxication Claims Warrantless DUI Defenses
Compel Discovery Motions Bank Statement DUI Defense
Brady Material in DUI Medical Issues Mistaken for DUI
Concussions Impair DUI Investigation Effective Trial Objections
Corroborating Eyewitness Testimony Officer Disciplinary Record Impact

Top-Rated DUI Lawyers Serving Florida

Looking for the best DUI lawyers in Florida? Our distinguished team of attorneys is committed to offering you the best possible defense against your DUI charges.

  • John Vallillo: As a stalwart in the Florida legal scene, John Vallillo has earned his stripes through a consistent record of case dismissals and proactive defense. His background as both a prosecutor and defense attorney enriches his strategic defense planning with invaluable insights.
  • Joe Easton: Renowned for crafting winning defenses, Joe Easton’s approach to legal advocacy in Florida combines thorough preparation with aggressive representation. His notable recognitions and ratings stand testament to his exceptional service and client-focused approach.
  • Joel Leppard: Joel Leppard infuses every DUI case with a level of personal commitment and innovative thinking that sets him apart. His leadership has not only grown Leppard Law into a top-rated criminal defense law firm but also ensured that clients receive empathetic, effective legal care.

Discover What Our Clients Are Saying

At the forefront of our DUI practice is a deep-seated commitment to client satisfaction. Each case is handled with utmost care, as echoed in the appreciative feedback from those we represent. Stellar reviews are what make us one consistently one of Central Florida’s top-rated DUI law firms. You can read more 5 star reviews here: https://leppardlaw.com/reviews/








Take Control of Your DUI Defense with Leppard Law

Understanding the lack of probable cause in your DUI arrest can be a game-changer. At Leppard Law: DUI Attorneys, we specialize in scrutinizing every detail of your case to ensure your rights are protected. With our extensive experience and dedication, we aim to get your breath test or refusal thrown out, potentially leading to the dismissal of your charges.

What does it look like to have a personal relationship with your attorney? Imagine having someone who knows you as well as they know your case, always having your back when things get tough. At Leppard Law, we treat our clients like family. We always put their best interests first and fight for the best possible outcome for their case.

But you don’t have to take our word for it—experience it for yourself. If you or a loved one has been charged with a DUI or any criminal offense, contact us today to schedule a free consultation. Call us at 407-476-4111 or visit our contact page.

Our accolades speak volumes about our commitment to excellence:

  • Named as one of the “Top Personal Injury Lawyers in Orlando, FL” 2023 by Expertise
  • Highlighted among the “Top Personal Injury Attorneys near Sanford, FL” for 2023 by Thumbtack
  • Listed among the “Best Car Accident Lawyers in Sanford” from 2016-2023 by Expertise
  • Recognized as one of the “Top 10 DUI Attorneys near Orlando, FL” by Thumbtack
  • Ranked as #1 on Yelp’s list of “Best Lawyers in Orlando” (2024)

At Leppard Law, we take immense pride in helping our clients navigate through some of life’s most challenging moments. Your trust and support have fueled our commitment to excellence, and we’re honored to be a part of our shared community. While we hope you never face a criminal charge, we want you to know that if the need arises, we’re here for you.

“From Their Bench to Your Defense” – As former prosecutors, we’ve sat on their side and mastered their playbook. Now, we’re in your corner, defending your rights with exceptional dedication and expertise.

ONE call to our top-rated criminal defense attorneys can make all the difference. Schedule your consultation today, and let us provide the support and legal expertise you deserve. Call us now at 407-476-4111 or visit our contact page to get started.

Trusted Content


Legally Reviewed by Joe Easton

Experienced Florida DUI Attorney

Legally reviewed by Joe Easton and the content team, this article reflects the firm’s 60 years of combined criminal defense expertise. Joe Easton, with his extensive experience and strategic prowess in DUI and criminal defense, offers more than just legal representation; he brings a commitment to turning legal challenges into triumphs. His approach, combining tenacity in the courtroom with personalized client care, ensures your DUI case is not just defended but championed with dedication and expertise.

Learn More About Joe Easton