fbpx

Punch Drunk: How Concussions and Other Head Injuries Impair the Ability of Police to Properly Investigate a DUI after a Motor Vehicle Accident?



Introduction to Concussions and Head Injuries in DUI Investigations

Concussions and other head injuries can significantly impair an individual’s ability to perform during a DUI investigation. When involved in a motor vehicle accident, these injuries can affect balance, speech, and cognitive functions, leading to inaccurate results in field sobriety tests and other assessments. Understanding how head injuries impact DUI investigations is crucial for both defendants and legal professionals.

The Impact of Head Injuries on Field Sobriety Tests

Field sobriety tests are designed to evaluate a person’s physical and cognitive abilities, but these tests can be misleading when the individual has suffered a concussion or head injury. Common tests such as the walk-and-turn, one-leg stand, and horizontal gaze nystagmus can be particularly challenging for someone with a head injury. These impairments can result in false positives, leading to wrongful DUI charges.

What are field sobriety tests? Field sobriety tests are assessments used by police officers to determine if a person is impaired. These tests evaluate balance, coordination, and cognitive function.

For instance, the walk-and-turn test requires an individual to walk in a straight line, turn on one foot, and return. This can be extremely difficult for someone with a head injury, as balance and coordination are often compromised. Similarly, the one-leg stand test demands excellent balance, which may be impossible for someone suffering from a concussion. Lastly, the horizontal gaze nystagmus test involves tracking an object with one’s eyes. A head injury can cause involuntary eye movements, leading to incorrect assumptions of intoxication.

It’s important to recognize that these tests are not foolproof. In fact, they can be highly unreliable, especially for individuals with medical conditions. If you’ve been involved in an accident and sustained a head injury, it’s essential to inform the officer immediately. This information can be crucial in ensuring that your condition is taken into account during the investigation.

Why is it important to inform the officer of your head injury? Informing the officer of your head injury ensures that they consider your condition during field sobriety tests. This can prevent wrongful DUI charges based on impaired performance due to the injury.

In Florida, the legal system recognizes that medical issues can affect the outcome of field sobriety tests. Therefore, it’s vital to communicate any injuries or conditions to the investigating officers. This can help in challenging the validity of the tests and potentially defending against DUI charges.

Understanding the impact of head injuries on field sobriety tests is just one aspect of a comprehensive DUI defense. Legal professionals must also consider other factors, such as procedural errors and the accuracy of breathalyzer tests, to build a strong case.

For more detailed information on how medical issues can be mistaken for signs of impairment, you can read about it here.

Challenges of Breathalyzer Tests After Head Injuries

Client celebrating walking out of courthouse in Florida after DUI case

Breathalyzer tests are a standard tool used by law enforcement to measure a driver’s blood alcohol concentration (BAC). However, when a person has sustained a head injury, the accuracy and reliability of these tests can be compromised. This section explores the specific challenges that arise when administering breathalyzer tests to individuals with concussions or other head injuries.

Procedural Errors in Administering Breathalyzer Tests

Police officers are required to follow strict protocols when administering breathalyzer tests. These protocols are designed to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the results. However, when a person is injured, these protocols may not be followed correctly. For instance, if the test is not administered multiple times as required, or if the individual cannot blow properly due to injury, the results may be invalid. These procedural errors can be critical in challenging DUI charges in court.

What are procedural errors in breathalyzer tests? Procedural errors in breathalyzer tests occur when the strict protocols for administering the test are not followed, potentially leading to inaccurate results.

Consider a scenario where a driver involved in an accident is suspected of DUI. The officer at the scene administers a breathalyzer test, but the driver, who has suffered a concussion, struggles to follow instructions. This can result in an incomplete or incorrect breath sample, leading to inaccurate BAC readings. In such cases, the validity of the breathalyzer test can be questioned in court.

Another critical factor is the timing of the test. After an accident, the body’s stress response can affect the metabolism of alcohol. The trauma from the accident, combined with a head injury, can cause fluctuations in BAC levels. This makes it essential to consider the timing of the breathalyzer test and whether it accurately reflects the driver’s BAC at the time of driving.

Why is the timing of a breathalyzer test important? The timing of a breathalyzer test is crucial because the body’s stress response to an accident can cause fluctuations in BAC levels, potentially leading to inaccurate results.

In Florida, the legal system recognizes that procedural errors and timing issues can impact the accuracy of breathalyzer tests. Therefore, it’s important to work with a skilled DUI attorney who can scrutinize the administration of the test and identify any potential errors or inconsistencies. This can be a key element in building a strong DUI defense.

Impact of Head Injuries on Breathalyzer Test Results

Head injuries, such as concussions, can significantly impact a person’s ability to perform breathalyzer tests accurately. The symptoms of a concussion, including dizziness, confusion, and difficulty following instructions, can make it challenging to provide a proper breath sample. This can result in false readings and wrongful DUI charges.

For example, a driver with a concussion may have difficulty understanding the officer’s instructions to blow steadily into the breathalyzer device. This can lead to an insufficient breath sample, which the device may interpret as a refusal to take the test. In Florida, refusing a breathalyzer test can lead to automatic license suspension and other penalties, even if the refusal was unintentional due to a head injury.

Additionally, the physiological effects of a concussion can alter the body’s metabolism of alcohol. The stress and trauma from the accident can cause the body to metabolize alcohol differently, leading to skewed BAC readings. This makes it essential to consider the medical condition of the driver when interpreting breathalyzer test results.

Given these challenges, it’s crucial to gather comprehensive medical evidence to support the claim that the driver’s impaired performance was due to a head injury rather than alcohol consumption. This evidence can include medical records, expert testimony, and accident reports. A skilled DUI attorney can use this evidence to challenge the accuracy of the breathalyzer test and potentially get the results thrown out in court.

How can medical evidence help in a DUI case? Medical evidence, including records, expert testimony, and accident reports, can help establish that a driver’s impaired performance was due to a head injury rather than alcohol consumption, challenging the accuracy of breathalyzer test results.

In conclusion, breathalyzer tests can be highly unreliable for individuals with head injuries. Procedural errors, timing issues, and the physiological effects of concussions can all contribute to inaccurate BAC readings. It’s essential to work with a knowledgeable DUI attorney who can identify these issues and build a strong defense. For more information on how medical issues can affect DUI investigations, you can read about it here.

Head injuries can have significant legal implications in DUI cases. When a defendant has suffered a concussion or another head injury, it can profoundly impact their ability to perform during sobriety tests. This section delves into how these injuries can be used as a defense strategy and what legal professionals need to consider.

Role of Medical Evidence in DUI Defense

Medical evidence plays a crucial role in DUI defense when head injuries are involved. Documentation of the injury, treatment records, and expert opinions can help establish that the defendant’s impaired abilities were due to the injury rather than alcohol consumption. This evidence can challenge the prosecution’s case and potentially lead to the dismissal of charges.

Consider a scenario where an individual involved in a motor vehicle accident is accused of DUI. The officer at the scene administers field sobriety tests, which the individual fails, struggling to balance and follow instructions. Later, it turns out that the individual had a head injury caused by the crash. In such cases, medical evidence can be pivotal in defending against DUI charges.

What is the role of medical evidence in DUI defense? Medical evidence, including documentation of injuries, treatment records, and expert opinions, can establish that a defendant’s impaired abilities were due to a head injury rather than alcohol consumption, challenging the prosecution’s case.

For instance, if you have a concussion, your balance, speech, and cognitive functions could be impaired. You might have trouble seeing or comprehending what you’re being asked to do during sobriety tests. This can result in false positives, leading to wrongful DUI charges. Medical records and expert testimony can provide a compelling argument for the defense, helping to cast doubt on the prosecution’s evidence.

Moreover, if you were under the legal limit but still charged with DUI, your attorney could argue that your impaired performance was due to the head injury. This is especially relevant in cases where the officer claimed that your breath test was .06%, yet you failed the field sobriety tests. The attorney could show that the failure was due to brain trauma, not intoxication.

In Florida, the legal system recognizes that head injuries can significantly impact a person’s ability to perform sobriety tests accurately. Therefore, it’s essential to gather comprehensive medical evidence to support your defense. This evidence can include:

  • Medical records: Detailed documentation of your head injury and treatment.
  • Expert testimony: Opinions from medical professionals explaining how the injury affected your abilities.
  • Accident reports: Documentation of the accident that caused the injury.

By leveraging this evidence, your attorney can challenge the validity of the sobriety tests and potentially get the charges dismissed. For more detailed strategies on defending DUI charges, you can read about winning DUI strategies.

Defending DUI charges involving head injuries requires a strategic approach. Legal professionals must thoroughly investigate the circumstances of the accident, the administration of sobriety tests, and the medical condition of the defendant. By highlighting the impact of the head injury on the defendant’s performance, attorneys can build a strong defense.

One effective strategy is to challenge the administration and results of the sobriety tests. For example, if the officer did not follow proper protocols or if the tests were not administered correctly, the results could be invalid. Additionally, the attorney could argue that the defendant’s impaired performance was due to the head injury, not intoxication.

Another critical strategy is to gather and present comprehensive medical evidence. This includes medical records, expert testimony, and accident reports. By demonstrating that the defendant’s impaired abilities were due to a head injury, the attorney can challenge the prosecution’s case and potentially get the charges dismissed.

Furthermore, it’s essential to scrutinize the timing of the breathalyzer test. The stress and trauma from the accident can influence the body’s metabolism, leading to skewed BAC readings. If the test was not administered correctly or at the right time, the results could be inaccurate. This can be a key element in building a strong DUI defense.

Why is it important to scrutinize the timing of a breathalyzer test? The timing of a breathalyzer test is crucial because the stress and trauma from an accident can influence the body’s metabolism, leading to skewed BAC readings and potentially inaccurate results.

In conclusion, head injuries can significantly impact DUI cases, and medical evidence plays a crucial role in defending against these charges. By gathering comprehensive medical documentation and expert testimony, legal professionals can challenge the prosecution’s case and potentially get the charges dismissed. For more information on how medical issues can affect DUI investigations, you can read about it here.


Strategies for Defending DUI Charges Involving Head Injuries

Defending DUI charges involving head injuries requires a strategic and thorough approach. Legal professionals must meticulously investigate the circumstances of the accident, the administration of sobriety tests, and the medical condition of the defendant. By highlighting the impact of the head injury on the defendant’s performance, attorneys can build a robust defense that challenges the prosecution’s case.

Importance of Expert Testimony

Expert testimony is often essential in DUI cases involving head injuries. Medical experts can explain how the injury affected the defendant’s abilities and challenge the validity of the sobriety tests. Their testimony can provide a compelling argument for the defense, helping to cast doubt on the prosecution’s evidence and strengthen the case for the defendant.

Why is expert testimony crucial in DUI cases involving head injuries? Expert testimony is crucial because medical experts can explain how a head injury affected the defendant’s abilities, challenging the validity of sobriety tests and strengthening the defense.

For example, if you were involved in a motor vehicle accident and suffered a concussion, the symptoms could significantly impair your performance during field sobriety tests. Medical experts can testify about the effects of concussions, such as dizziness, balance issues, and cognitive impairments, which can easily be mistaken for signs of intoxication. This testimony can be pivotal in challenging the accuracy of the sobriety tests and the breathalyzer results.

Additionally, expert testimony can address procedural errors in administering the tests. If a breathalyzer test was not conducted properly or if the field sobriety tests were administered without considering the head injury, an expert can highlight these flaws. This can be instrumental in getting the test results dismissed or questioned by the court.

Gathering Comprehensive Medical Evidence

Medical evidence is a cornerstone of defending DUI charges involving head injuries. Comprehensive documentation of the injury, treatment records, and expert opinions are essential in establishing that the defendant’s impaired abilities were due to the injury rather than alcohol consumption. This evidence can challenge the prosecution’s case and potentially lead to the dismissal of charges.

  • Medical records: Detailed documentation of the head injury and subsequent treatment.
  • Expert opinions: Testimony from medical professionals explaining the impact of the injury on the defendant’s abilities.
  • Accident reports: Documentation of the accident that caused the injury, which can provide context for the defense.

For instance, if you were under the legal limit but still charged with DUI, your attorney could argue that your impaired performance was due to the head injury. This is especially relevant in cases where the officer claimed that your breath test was .06%, yet you failed the field sobriety tests. The attorney could show that the failure was due to brain trauma, not intoxication.

Challenging the Administration of Sobriety Tests

Field sobriety tests are designed to evaluate a person’s physical and cognitive abilities, but these tests can be misleading when the individual has suffered a concussion or head injury. Common tests such as the walk-and-turn, one-leg stand, and horizontal gaze nystagmus can be particularly challenging for someone with a head injury. These impairments can result in false positives, leading to wrongful DUI charges.

Punch Drunk: How Concussions and Other Head Injuries Impair the Ability of Police to Properly Investigate a DUI after a Motor Vehicle Accident

One effective strategy is to challenge the administration and results of the sobriety tests. For example, if the officer did not follow proper protocols or if the tests were not administered correctly, the results could be invalid. Additionally, the attorney could argue that the defendant’s impaired performance was due to the head injury, not intoxication.

Moreover, it’s essential to scrutinize the timing of the breathalyzer test. The stress and trauma from the accident can influence the body’s metabolism, leading to skewed BAC readings. If the test was not administered correctly or at the right time, the results could be inaccurate. This can be a key element in building a strong DUI defense.

Legal precedents and case law can also play a significant role in defending DUI charges involving head injuries. Attorneys can reference previous cases where head injuries were successfully used as a defense to challenge the prosecution’s evidence. This can help establish a legal framework for the defense and provide a roadmap for challenging the charges.

For example, in Bragg v. State, 644 So.2d 586 (Fla. 1st DCA 1994), the court recognized the impact of head injuries on a defendant’s ability to perform sobriety tests. By referencing similar cases, your attorney can build a compelling argument that highlights the flaws in the prosecution’s case and strengthens your defense.

Additionally, leveraging legal precedents can help challenge the officer’s observations and procedures during the DUI investigation. Any deviations from standard protocols or inconsistencies in the officer’s report can be used to cast doubt on the prosecution’s case. For more information on how to challenge DUI investigations, you can read about it here.

Focusing on Rehabilitation and Recovery

Throughout the legal process, it’s essential for you to focus on your rehabilitation and recovery. Head injuries can have long-lasting effects, and prioritizing your health is crucial. By working with medical professionals and following their treatment plans, you can improve your chances of a full recovery and provide additional evidence for your defense.

Your attorney’s job is to look at the evidence that the police say they collected and to go through it. If something like a walk-and-turn test was failed, your attorney may be able to show that you failed it due to brain trauma. Similarly, if you were not given the Breathalyzer test correctly or as many times as required, your attorney could work to have those results thrown out or questioned by the court as well.

In conclusion, defending DUI charges involving head injuries requires a strategic approach that leverages medical evidence, expert testimony, and legal precedents. By thoroughly investigating the circumstances of the accident and the administration of sobriety tests, attorneys can build a strong defense that challenges the prosecution’s case and protects the defendant’s rights.


Infographic depicting the words Punch Drunk: How Concussions and Other Head Injuries Impair the Ability of Police to Properly Investigate a DUI after a Motor Vehicle Accident?


How do concussions affect DUI field sobriety tests?

Concussions can significantly impair an individual’s ability to perform DUI field sobriety tests. These injuries can affect balance, speech, and cognitive functions, leading to inaccurate results. Common tests such as the walk-and-turn, one-leg stand, and horizontal gaze nystagmus can be particularly challenging for someone with a head injury, resulting in false positives and wrongful DUI charges.

Can a head injury impact the accuracy of a breathalyzer test?

Yes, a head injury can impact the accuracy of a breathalyzer test. A person with a concussion may have difficulty following instructions, which can affect the test’s results. Additionally, the stress and trauma from the accident can influence the body’s metabolism, leading to skewed blood alcohol concentration (BAC) readings.

What medical evidence is needed to defend against DUI charges involving head injuries?

To defend against DUI charges involving head injuries, comprehensive medical evidence is essential. This includes detailed documentation of the injury, treatment records, and expert opinions. Medical experts can testify about the effects of the injury on the defendant’s abilities, challenging the validity of sobriety tests and breathalyzer results. Accident reports can also provide context for the defense.

Why is expert testimony crucial in DUI cases involving head injuries?

Expert testimony is crucial in DUI cases involving head injuries because medical experts can explain how the injury affected the defendant’s abilities. They can challenge the validity of sobriety tests and provide a compelling argument for the defense. This testimony can help cast doubt on the prosecution’s evidence and strengthen the case for the defendant.

Explore additional areas of practice that we specialize in to better understand how we can assist you with your legal needs.

DUI Defense Guide Winning DUI Strategies
Strengthen DUI Defense Motion to Suppress Impact
Intervening Causes in DUI Duress DUI Defense
Involuntary Intoxication Claims Lack of Probable Cause
Warrantless DUI Defenses Compel Discovery Motions
Bank Statement DUI Defense Brady Material in DUI
Medical Issues Mistaken for DUI Effective Trial Objections
Corroborating Eyewitness Testimony Officer Disciplinary Record Impact

Top-Rated DUI Lawyers Serving Florida

Looking for the best DUI lawyers in Florida? Our distinguished team of attorneys is committed to offering you the best possible defense against your DUI charges.

  • John Vallillo: As a stalwart in the Florida legal scene, John Vallillo has earned his stripes through a consistent record of case dismissals and proactive defense. His background as both a prosecutor and defense attorney enriches his strategic defense planning with invaluable insights.
  • Joe Easton: Renowned for crafting winning defenses, Joe Easton’s approach to legal advocacy in Florida combines thorough preparation with aggressive representation. His notable recognitions and ratings stand testament to his exceptional service and client-focused approach.
  • Joel Leppard: Joel Leppard infuses every DUI case with a level of personal commitment and innovative thinking that sets him apart. His leadership has not only grown Leppard Law into a top-rated criminal defense law firm but also ensured that clients receive empathetic, effective legal care.

Discover What Our Clients Are Saying

At the forefront of our DUI practice is a deep-seated commitment to client satisfaction. Each case is handled with utmost care, as echoed in the appreciative feedback from those we represent. Stellar reviews are what make us consistently one of Central Florida’s top-rated DUI law firms. You can read more 5-star reviews here.








Take Control of Your DUI Case Today

Dealing with the aftermath of a concussion or head injury can be incredibly stressful, especially when it impacts the police investigation of a DUI. At Leppard Law: DUI Attorneys, we understand the complexities involved and are here to support you every step of the way.

What does it look like to have a personal relationship with your attorney? Someone who has your back when things get tough? A lawyer that knows you as well as they know your case? At Leppard Law, we treat our clients like family. We always put their best interests first and fight for the best possible outcome for their case.

But you don’t have to take our word for it – experience it for yourself. If you or a loved one has been charged with a criminal offense, contact us today to schedule a free consultation. Call us at 407-476-4111.

“From Their Bench to Your Defense” – As former prosecutors, we’ve sat on their side and mastered their playbook. Now, we’re in your corner, defending your rights with exceptional dedication and expertise. At Leppard Law, we turn our insider knowledge into your strongest defense.

Our firm has been recognized for excellence and client satisfaction, earning accolades that reflect our dedication:

  • Named as one of the “Top Personal Injury Lawyers in Orlando, FL” 2023 by Expertise
  • Highlighted among the “Top Personal Injury Attorneys near Sanford, FL” for 2023 by Thumbtack
  • Listed among the “Best Car Accident Lawyers in Sanford” from 2016-2023 by Expertise
  • Recognized as one of the “Top 10 DUI Attorneys near Orlando, FL” by Thumbtack
  • Ranked as #1 on Yelp’s list of “Best Lawyers in Orlando” (2024)

At Leppard Law, we take immense pride in helping our clients navigate through some of life’s most challenging moments. Your trust and support have fueled our commitment to excellence, and we’re honored to be a part of our shared community.

While we hope you never face a criminal charge, we want you to know that if the need arises, we’re here for you. One call to our top-rated criminal defense attorneys can make all the difference. Schedule your consultation today, and let us provide the support and legal expertise you deserve.

Don’t let a DUI charge define your future. Take control of your case today by scheduling a free consultation with our top-rated criminal defense attorneys. Call us now at 407-476-4111 or visit our contact page to get started.

Trusted Content


Legally Reviewed by Joe Easton

Experienced Florida DUI Attorney

Legally reviewed by Joe Easton and the content team, this article delves into the complexities of how concussions and head injuries can impair police investigations in DUI cases. Joe Easton, with his extensive experience and strategic prowess in DUI and criminal defense, offers more than just legal representation; he brings a commitment to turning legal challenges into triumphs. His approach, combining tenacity in the courtroom with personalized client care, ensures your DUI case is not just defended but championed with dedication and expertise.

Learn More About Joe Easton