fbpx

How We Challenge HGN Evidence and Win in 99% of Our DUI Cases



Understanding Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) in DUI Cases

The Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) test is a crucial component of field sobriety exercises used during DUI investigations. HGN refers to the involuntary jerking of the eyes as they gaze to the side, often unnoticed by the individual. This test is typically the first exercise performed by law enforcement officers to determine impairment. However, it’s important to note that nystagmus can be caused by factors other than alcohol consumption.

What is Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus? Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus is an involuntary jerking of the eyes as they gaze toward the side, often used in field sobriety tests to assess impairment.

During the HGN test, the officer will move a stimulus, such as a pen or finger, in front of the suspect’s eyes in at least 14 passes. The suspect is instructed to follow the stimulus with their eyes only, without moving their head. Proper administration of this test is critical, as any deviation from the standardized procedure can affect the test’s reliability.

Administering the HGN Test

Administering the HGN test involves several specific steps:

  1. Initial Positioning: The officer instructs the suspect to remove their glasses, if any, and to keep their head still.
  2. Stimulus Movement: The officer moves the stimulus side-to-side in front of the suspect’s eyes, ensuring the movement is smooth and consistent.
  3. Observation of Eye Movement: The officer observes the eyes for jerking as they follow the stimulus, making at least 14 passes to ensure accuracy.

It’s essential that the officer follows the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) guidelines strictly. Any deviation, such as moving the stimulus too quickly or holding it too close, can render the test results unreliable.

At Leppard Law, we understand the intricacies involved in administering the HGN test. Our expertise allows us to identify any procedural errors that may have occurred during your DUI investigation. By scrutinizing the administration of the HGN test, we can challenge the validity of the evidence presented against you.

If you’re facing a DUI charge and have undergone an HGN test, it’s crucial to have the test results reviewed by an experienced attorney. Our team at Leppard Law is well-versed in the NHTSA guidelines and can provide the skilled representation you need to challenge the evidence effectively. For more information on field sobriety tests, check out our Ultimate Guide to FSEs in Florida.

DUI Lawyer Documents

Understanding the HGN test and its administration is the first step in building a robust defense against DUI charges. For further insights into field sobriety tests, visit our page on the effectiveness of the One Leg Stand test and learn how we can help you challenge the evidence against you.

Common Mistakes in Administering HGN Tests

Law enforcement officers often make errors when administering the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) test, which can lead to unreliable results. Some common mistakes include:

  • Moving the stimulus too quickly or too slowly on individual passes
  • Holding the stimulus closer than 12 inches or more than 15 inches away
  • Not holding the stimulus for at least four seconds at maximum deviation
  • Looping or curving the stimulus in an upward, downward, or circular motion

These errors can significantly impact the outcome of the test, making it essential for defense attorneys to scrutinize the administration of the HGN test in DUI cases.

DUI Sobriety Test

One major issue with the HGN test is the variability in how officers are trained to administer it. While the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) guidelines provide a standardized procedure, many officers deviate from these instructions. This deviation can occur for various reasons, such as lack of training, oversight, or simply rushing through the test. When an officer fails to follow the guidelines precisely, the reliability of the test is compromised.

Another common mistake is the failure to account for environmental factors. The HGN test requires a certain level of concentration and environmental stability. For instance, flashing lights from patrol cars or uneven surfaces can distract the subject and affect their ability to follow the stimulus with their eyes. Such conditions can lead to false positives, where the nystagmus observed is not due to alcohol impairment but rather external distractions.

Moreover, officers often neglect to ask critical questions before administering the test. According to the NHTSA guidelines, officers should inquire if the subject has any medical conditions that might affect the results, such as a history of head trauma or neurological disorders. Failing to ask these questions can lead to misinterpretation of the test results, as certain medical conditions can cause nystagmus independently of alcohol consumption.

What are common mistakes in administering the HGN test? Common mistakes include moving the stimulus too quickly or slowly, holding the stimulus at incorrect distances, not maintaining maximum deviation, and failing to account for medical conditions.

It’s also worth noting that the officer’s position relative to the subject can influence the test’s accuracy. The NHTSA guidelines recommend that the officer stand at eye level with the subject and ensure that the stimulus is moved horizontally. Any deviation from this can skew the results, as the subject might have to strain their eyes in an unnatural way to follow the stimulus. This straining can mimic the jerking motion indicative of nystagmus, leading to incorrect conclusions about the subject’s impairment.

At Leppard Law, we meticulously scrutinize each aspect of the HGN test to identify any procedural errors that may have occurred. Our attorneys are well-versed in the intricacies of the NHTSA guidelines and understand the common pitfalls officers encounter during the test. By highlighting these mistakes, we can challenge the admissibility of the HGN evidence, potentially leading to a more favorable outcome for our clients.

Additionally, it’s crucial to understand that the HGN test is just one part of the field sobriety exercises used to determine impairment. Officers often administer other tests, such as the Walk and Turn and One Leg Stand tests, which also have their own set of challenges and common mistakes. For example, the Walk and Turn test requires the subject to walk in a straight line, turn, and walk back. Environmental factors, the subject’s physical condition, and even the officer’s instructions can all impact the test’s reliability.

If you believe that errors were made during your HGN test, it’s essential to seek legal representation immediately. Our team at Leppard Law has a proven track record of identifying and challenging these errors in court. For more information on how we can assist you, visit our One Leg Stand test effectiveness page.

Understanding the common mistakes in administering the HGN test is crucial for anyone facing DUI charges. By being aware of these potential errors, you can better prepare your defense and challenge the evidence against you. Contact us today at 407-476-4111 or visit our contact page to schedule a free consultation and learn how we can help you navigate your DUI case.

Challenging HGN Evidence in Court

In Florida, the admissibility of Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) evidence in court is a contentious issue. Prosecutors are generally not allowed to present testimony about a suspect’s performance on the HGN test unless the officer administering the test has received specialized training, such as being a Drug Recognition Evaluator (DRE). Even then, the testimony must meet the traditional predicates of scientific evidence to be considered valid.

Excluding or Suppressing HGN Testimony

Defense attorneys can file motions to exclude or suppress HGN testimony by arguing that it constitutes scientific evidence requiring a qualified expert witness. Courts have ruled that lay observations of intoxication based on HGN are not admissible. Proper objections and legal arguments can prevent the introduction of unreliable HGN evidence in DUI trials.

One effective strategy is to challenge the officer’s qualifications and the conditions under which the HGN test was administered. According to the Ultimate Guide to FSEs in Florida, the officer must follow strict protocols outlined by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). Any deviation from these guidelines can render the test results inadmissible.

What is the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus test? The Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus test is an evaluation used to detect involuntary eye jerking when the eyes gaze to the side, often used in DUI investigations.

Another approach is to question the environmental conditions during the test. For example, if the test was conducted in a poorly lit area or with distracting lights from patrol cars, the results could be skewed. This is crucial because external factors can cause nystagmus, making the test unreliable. For more insights on the impact of environmental factors, check out our page on weather conditions and FSEs.

Defense attorneys can also argue that the HGN test was improperly administered. Common mistakes include moving the stimulus too quickly or slowly, holding it at incorrect distances, or not maintaining the stimulus at maximum deviation for the required time. These errors can significantly impact the test’s reliability, as noted in our article on common mistakes in administering field sobriety tests.

Moreover, the defense can highlight the fact that many medical conditions can cause nystagmus, independent of alcohol consumption. Conditions such as head injuries, neurological disorders, and even certain medications can result in involuntary eye jerking. This makes it essential to consider the subject’s medical history before relying on HGN results. For a deeper understanding of how medical conditions affect FSEs, visit our page on medical conditions and FSEs.

It’s also important to scrutinize the officer’s training and experience. In Florida, only officers who have received specialized training, such as Drug Recognition Evaluators (DREs), are qualified to testify about HGN results. Even then, their testimony must meet the traditional predicates of scientific evidence. The use of expert witnesses can be invaluable in challenging the officer’s qualifications and the scientific validity of the HGN test.

Another crucial aspect to consider is the legal precedent set by Florida courts. In State v. Meador, the Florida Supreme Court explained why testimony about HGN should be excluded from trial unless the traditional predicates of scientific evidence are satisfied. This ruling underscores the importance of having a qualified expert witness to testify about HGN results. For more information on how legal precedents affect DUI cases, check out our page on how to beat your DUI case.

At Leppard Law, we meticulously analyze every aspect of the HGN test to identify procedural errors and challenge the admissibility of the evidence. Our attorneys are well-versed in the NHTSA guidelines and understand the intricacies of the HGN test, ensuring that we leave no stone unturned in our defense strategy.

If you believe that errors were made during your HGN test, it’s essential to seek legal representation immediately. Our team at Leppard Law has a proven track record of identifying and challenging these errors in court. For more information on how we can assist you, visit our contact page to schedule a free consultation.


Why Leppard Law Wins 99% of DUI Cases Involving HGN Evidence

At Leppard Law, we have built an impressive record of success in challenging Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) evidence in DUI cases. Our approach is meticulous, evidence-based, and deeply rooted in a thorough understanding of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) guidelines. By scrutinizing every detail of the HGN test administration, we can identify procedural errors that can render the test results unreliable and inadmissible in court.

One of the key reasons for our success is our in-depth knowledge of the Ultimate Guide to FSEs in Florida. This guide provides comprehensive insights into the standardized procedures for field sobriety exercises, including the HGN test. By adhering strictly to these guidelines, we can pinpoint any deviations made by law enforcement officers during the test administration.

Our attorneys are well-versed in the common mistakes that officers make when administering the HGN test. These mistakes can significantly impact the reliability of the test results. For instance, officers often move the stimulus too quickly or too slowly, hold it at incorrect distances, or fail to maintain the stimulus at maximum deviation for the required time. By highlighting these errors, we can effectively challenge the validity of the HGN evidence. For more details on these common mistakes, visit our page on officer mistakes in FSEs.

Another critical aspect of our defense strategy is to question the qualifications and training of the officer who administered the HGN test. In Florida, only officers who have received specialized training, such as Drug Recognition Evaluators (DREs), are qualified to testify about HGN results. Even then, their testimony must meet the traditional predicates of scientific evidence. We ensure that the officer’s qualifications and adherence to NHTSA guidelines are thoroughly examined. For more information on the role of expert witnesses in challenging FSEs, see our page on expert witnesses for FSEs.

What is the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus test? The Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus test is an evaluation used to detect involuntary eye jerking when the eyes gaze to the side, often used in DUI investigations.

We also focus on the environmental conditions under which the HGN test was administered. Factors such as poor lighting, distracting lights from patrol cars, or uneven surfaces can all affect the test results. By bringing these factors to light, we can argue that the test conditions were not conducive to obtaining reliable results. This is particularly important in Florida, where weather conditions can also play a significant role. For a deeper understanding of how environmental factors can impact FSEs, visit our page on weather conditions and FSEs.

Medical conditions can also cause nystagmus, making it essential to consider the suspect’s medical history before relying on HGN results. Conditions such as head injuries, neurological disorders, and certain medications can result in involuntary eye jerking. Our attorneys are skilled at presenting these medical factors to challenge the reliability of the HGN test. For more insights on the impact of medical conditions, check out our article on medical conditions and FSEs.

In addition to challenging the administration and conditions of the HGN test, we also focus on the legal precedents set by Florida courts. In State v. Meador, the Florida Supreme Court explained why testimony about HGN should be excluded from trial unless the traditional predicates of scientific evidence are satisfied. This ruling underscores the importance of having a qualified expert witness to testify about HGN results. For more information on how legal precedents affect DUI cases, visit our page on how to beat your DUI case.

Our commitment to thorough investigation and expert legal representation ensures that we can identify and exploit weaknesses in the prosecution’s case. This approach has helped us achieve favorable outcomes for our clients, including dismissals and reductions of charges. Our attorneys are dedicated to providing personalized attention to each case, ensuring that our clients receive the best possible defense. For more information on our services, visit our contact page to schedule a free consultation.

At Leppard Law, we understand the stress and anxiety that comes with facing a DUI charge. Our team is here to provide the support and legal expertise you need to navigate through this challenging time. With a proven track record of success in challenging HGN evidence, we are confident in our ability to help you achieve a favorable outcome. Contact us today at 407-476-4111 to learn more about how we can assist you.

For additional information on DUI defenses, check out our comprehensive guide on how to beat your DUI case. Our attorneys are ready to fight for your rights and provide the expert legal representation you deserve.

Leppard Law Office

If you have been charged with a DUI, don’t wait to seek legal representation. The sooner you contact us, the better we can prepare your defense. Trust Leppard Law to provide the dedicated and expert legal support you need. Call us today at 407-476-4111 or visit our contact page to schedule a free consultation.


Infographic depicting the words How We Challenge HGN Evidence and Win in 99% of Our DUI Cases


What is the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus test?

What is the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus test? The Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus test, often referred to as HGN, is a field sobriety exercise used to detect involuntary jerking of the eyes as they gaze to the side, which can indicate impairment by alcohol.

How can HGN evidence be challenged in court?

How can HGN evidence be challenged in court? HGN evidence can be challenged by questioning the officer’s training, highlighting procedural errors, and arguing that the test results constitute scientific evidence requiring expert testimony.

What are common mistakes officers make during the HGN test?

What are common mistakes officers make during the HGN test? Common mistakes include moving the stimulus too quickly or slowly, holding the stimulus too close or too far, and not holding the stimulus at maximum deviation for the required time.

Why is specialized training important for administering the HGN test?

Why is specialized training important for administering the HGN test? Specialized training, such as being a Drug Recognition Evaluator (DRE), ensures that the officer follows the proper procedures, which is critical for the test’s reliability and admissibility in court.

For more detailed information about the different types of field sobriety exercises, visit our Ultimate Guide to Field Sobriety Exercises in Florida. If you are facing DUI charges and believe that errors were made during your HGN test, contact Leppard Law at 407-476-4111 for expert legal assistance.


Explore additional practice areas we specialize in to better understand the comprehensive legal services we offer:

Ultimate Guide to FSEs in Florida Challenging HGN Evidence
Challenging Walk and Turn Test Effectiveness of One Leg Stand Test
Officer Mistakes in FSEs Junk Science Behind FSEs
Medical Conditions and FSEs Fighting DUI Based on Improper FSEs
Refusing Field Sobriety Tests Expert Witnesses for FSEs
Footwear and FSE Performance Standard Field Sobriety Tests
Weather Conditions and FSEs Role of FSEs in DUI Cases
Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus Test FSE Video Admissibility

Top-Rated DUI Lawyers Serving Florida

Looking for the best DUI lawyers in Florida? Our distinguished team of attorneys is committed to offering you the best possible defense against your DUI charges.

  • John Vallillo: As a stalwart in the Florida legal scene, John Vallillo has earned his stripes through a consistent record of case dismissals and proactive defense. His background as both a prosecutor and defense attorney enriches his strategic defense planning with invaluable insights.
  • Joe Easton: Renowned for crafting winning defenses, Joe Easton’s approach to legal advocacy in Florida combines thorough preparation with aggressive representation. His notable recognitions and ratings stand testament to his exceptional service and client-focused approach.
  • Joel Leppard: Joel Leppard infuses every DUI case with a level of personal commitment and innovative thinking that sets him apart. His leadership has not only grown Leppard Law into a top-rated criminal defense law firm but also ensured that clients receive empathetic, effective legal care.